- Torah Portion and Tanach
- Va'etchanan
The Torah study is dedicated in the memory of
Yaakov Ben Behora
Parashat Vaetchanan
The Seven Prophecies of Consolation
It is the practice in the many Jewish communities of the world that this week we begin a series of reading seven prophecies of consolation (shiva d’nechemta) of the prophet, Yeshayahu, most of which are concentrated in chapters 40-66. In another place, we have demonstrated that Sefer Yeshayahu is consistently organized on a chronological basis. It starts with the period of Uziyah (see explicit reference in ch. 6), continues with the period of Achaz, is followed by that of Chizkiya (see ch. 36-39), and ends at the time of Menashe. Menashe is not mentioned explicitly in the book, not in the introduction and not in the beginning of the section of prophecies which we believe were said in his time. However, there are strong indications that the section which is the source for the shiva d’nechemta was said at the end of Yeshayahu’s life, during the horrible period of Menashe. We will need to explain why these optimistic prophecies were said specifically at that time.
Our Rabbis have passed on a tradition (see Rashi on Hoshea 1:1) that only righteous kings are mentioned in the headings of the books of the prophets. A wicked king will be mentioned only if both his father and his son were righteous and he is swallowed up in a progression of those who are fit to be mentioned. (The classic example is Achaz.) For that reason, Menashe was not mentioned in Yeshayahu. Chazal were sure that Yeshayahu did operate in Menashe’s time, for they relate that Menashe actually killed Yeshayahu, his maternal grandfather (Yevamot 49b). Menashe was considered the worst of all of the kings that ruled over Judea. His sins included the classic anti-religious travesty of promulgating idol worship but also included the human abomination of multiple murder (see Melachim II, 21: 2-9, 16). He is also the one identified as most responsible for the pending destruction of the First Temple, which was decreed in his time, although it was carried out during the reign of his descendant, Tzidkiyahu (see Yirmeyahu 15: 1-3).
So why were there so many optimistic prophecies at the time of so much sinning? A prophet is not a newspaper columnist to report what is transpiring in his time. Rather, it is his job to bring the word of Hashem to the people. At the relatively strong time of Uziyah there was a need to warn the people about the difficult future of the Assyrian conquest. In contrast, when Bnei Yisrael had reached a low at the time of Menashe, there was a fear that they would feel so overwhelmed by what was required of them to reach the proper level. They might give up hope and decide that Hashem had given up on them once and for all. The prophet came and pronounced clearly, "Be consoled, be consoled, My nation, says your Lord."
Let us pray that we too will merit seeing the continuation of the fulfillment of the prophecies of consolation.
Our Rabbis have passed on a tradition (see Rashi on Hoshea 1:1) that only righteous kings are mentioned in the headings of the books of the prophets. A wicked king will be mentioned only if both his father and his son were righteous and he is swallowed up in a progression of those who are fit to be mentioned. (The classic example is Achaz.) For that reason, Menashe was not mentioned in Yeshayahu. Chazal were sure that Yeshayahu did operate in Menashe’s time, for they relate that Menashe actually killed Yeshayahu, his maternal grandfather (Yevamot 49b). Menashe was considered the worst of all of the kings that ruled over Judea. His sins included the classic anti-religious travesty of promulgating idol worship but also included the human abomination of multiple murder (see Melachim II, 21: 2-9, 16). He is also the one identified as most responsible for the pending destruction of the First Temple, which was decreed in his time, although it was carried out during the reign of his descendant, Tzidkiyahu (see Yirmeyahu 15: 1-3).
So why were there so many optimistic prophecies at the time of so much sinning? A prophet is not a newspaper columnist to report what is transpiring in his time. Rather, it is his job to bring the word of Hashem to the people. At the relatively strong time of Uziyah there was a need to warn the people about the difficult future of the Assyrian conquest. In contrast, when Bnei Yisrael had reached a low at the time of Menashe, there was a fear that they would feel so overwhelmed by what was required of them to reach the proper level. They might give up hope and decide that Hashem had given up on them once and for all. The prophet came and pronounced clearly, "Be consoled, be consoled, My nation, says your Lord."
Let us pray that we too will merit seeing the continuation of the fulfillment of the prophecies of consolation.

Honor the Elderly!
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Av 12 5781

Listening while Seeking Face to Face
Rabbi Yossef Carmel | Av 8 5777

The Fewest of All Peoples
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks | Av 13 5781

Making Love Last
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks | Av14 5778

Rabbi Yossef Carmel
Head of "Eretz Hemda" Dayanut Kollel

A Telling Drink
Parashat Miketz
Mikeitz-Chanuka 2 Tevet 5764

The System of Appointing Kings
Parashat Vayishlach
5764

Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair Said: “Purity Leads to Sanctity”
5771

The Two Countings of the Nation, Yom Haatzmaut and Yom Yerushalayim
Iyar 26 5777

The Law of Bar Metzra
Various Rabbis | 5774

Milk Spoon in a Meat Sink or Dishwasher
Kashrut in a Nutshell
Rabbi David Sperling

The Great Crock Pot Controversy
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Iyar 5768

Igrot Hare’aya – Letters of Rav Kook
Introduction
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Tevet 8 5781

Shadow and Fear
Rabbi Haggai Lundin | Av 3 5782

Natural Life in the Land of Israel & the Tragedy of Galut
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Av 1 5782

Retribution and Revenge
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks | Av 1 5782
