- Sections
- P'ninat Mishpat
801
Let us deal now with a doctor who acted negligently. The Ramban says that his exemption is contingent on his being careful as one would expect regarding matters of life and death and not damage through negligence. It is unclear, though, whether when he is not exempt, his obligation is legal or only moral. The Perisha (Yoreh Deah 336:6) and Shach (336:2) say that the exemption refers to cases of mistakes, not intentional damage, which implies that a doctor would be exempt in a case of negligence. The Tosefta in Gittin (3:8) also distinguishes between a mistake and an intentional act. On the other hand, the Tosefta in Bava Kama (9:11) indicates that the obligation extends beyond cases of intentional damage. However, the the Aruch Hashulchan (YD 336:2) and B’er Moshe (84) say that his obligation is either for exile for death or a moral obligation of damages. In this way, he answers the Yad Avraham’s (YD 336:1) question of why someone who is authorized by beit din should require exile if he kills if, in general, one who kills during authorized activity (e.g., one who carries out corporal punishment for beit din) is exempt from exile. The answer is that here we are talking about one who was particularly negligent.
The Tashbetz (III, 82) also does not obligate in cases of simple negligence; however, he explains the obligation of the Tosefta in Bava Kama as a full legal obligation. He posits that the doctor’s exemption is when the diagnosis and strategy were correct, just that a mistake was made during the treatment. When the entire treatment was flawed, it turns out that he was not involved in healing. Based on this approach, the Shevet Halevi (IV, 151) says that if a doctor operated in a location he should not have, he may be obligated. Only if it was not possible to determine where he should have operated would we say that he is exempt because of extenuating circumstances.
Along similar lines, the Tzitz Eliezer (V, Ramat Rachel 23) says that if a doctor made the right diagnosis but injected the wrong substance, he is obligated. Here too, he turned out to not have been healing, and he follows the rules of a regular person who damaged. In contrast, if the therapeutic steps were planned and basically carried out correctly, just that their quality was sub-par, he is exempt as long as he did not do so intentionally.
Still it seems that if he strayed from the accepted guidelines, he is obligated. After all, the doctor’s exemption is in order to encourage people to be involved in the medical field. Punishing one who does not follow guidelines does not distance people from the field; on the contrary, it encourages better medical care, as it is good for a doctor to know that if he fails to do as he is supposed to, he may have to pay for it. Only when he exerted the expected effort and was not able to succeed is he exempt.

P'ninat Mishpat (762)
Various Rabbis
145 - Medical Malpractice
146 - Medical Malpractice
147 - Disqualifications of Witnesses
Load More

P'ninat Mishpat: Realtor Fee Despite the Buyer’s Refusal?
based on ruling 83117 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Kislev 5784

P'ninat Mishpat: Unpaid Fees of a No-Show to Beit Din
based on ruling 84052 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Shevat 5784

An Unavoidable Cancellation
Various Rabbis | 5774

P'ninat Mishpat: Proof Needed to Remove a Squatter – part I
based on ruling 81116 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Cheshvan 5784

Igrot Hare’aya – Letters of Rav Kook
Introduction
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Tevet 8 5781

What Is the Significance of the Number 40 in Jewish Tradition?
Rabbi Stewart Weiss | Tevet 4 5782

That a Cohen May Not Marry a Divorcee
Rabbi Shmuel Holshtein | 5769

What Is the Significance of the Number 40 in Jewish Tradition?
Rabbi Stewart Weiss | Tevet 4 5782
Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 55
R' Eli Stefansky | 12 Shevat 5785

Nothing Like Prayer with Repentance
Rabbi Avraham Shapira Zt"l | 16 Shvat 5785

THANK TRUMP BUT SING TO G-D & the IDF- Parshat Beshalach & Tu BiShvat
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Shevat 5785 11
