Ask the Rabbi: Halachic Status of Hydroponic Maror | Rabbi Daniel Mann | Beit Midrash

Beit Midrash

Sections
Chemdat Yamim
Bemare Habazak - Rabbis Questions

קטגוריה משנית

Parashat Hashavua Series'Library Piskei Din (Hebrew)Test Yourself

Question: I know that the beracha for hydroponically grown vegetables, such as the insect-free romaine lettuce used for Pesach, is Shehakol since it is grown in water, not soil. May one use it for the Seder as maror and, if so, does one say then Shehakol or Borei Pri Ha’adamah?

Answer: I understand that most "insect-free" vegetables are not hydroponically grown but use other methods to minimize the chance of insects. We will discuss the cases of hydroponically grown romaine lettuce, but our main focus will be on the correctness of your assumption that the beracha is Shehakol.
The Yerushalmi (Kilayim 7:6) questions whether one recites Hamotzi on bread made from grain that grew in a flowerpot without holes (atzit she’eino nakuv = ashn). Based on this, the Chayei Adam (I, 51:17) instructs to make Mezonot on such bread, and Shehakol on similarly grown vegetables. The issue is the language of "…min ha’aretz" (from the land) and "pri ha’adama" (fruit of the soil), which may not be sufficiently accurate in these cases. Regarding fruit of a tree that grew in an ashn, he is less sure because perhaps that is still called pri ha’etz. Presumably hydroponic produce is less connected to land/soil than that which grows in an ashn. (Note that there are always nutrients in the water, and in some systems (aggregate), there are elements present that could arguably make it considered watery soil.)
We can question the Chayei Adam’s position based on logic and sources. It is logical to argue that foods are categorized for berachot based on the species’ characteristics, irrespective of the specific item one is eating. Regarding sources, the conclusion of the Yerushalmi (ibid.) is disputable, and a different Yerushalmi (Berachot 6:1) indicates Hamotzi for such bread. It says that whatever food gets Birkat Hamazon after it, gets Hamotzi before it, and the gemara (Berachot 47b) assumes we make Birkat Hamazon after bread that originates from an ashn. This encourages some (see S’dei Chemed VI, p. 279) to make Hamotzi on bread from an ashn, as the Rambam (Berachot 3:11) may imply.
How do we pasken? The Chayei Adam is more equivocal elsewhere (Nishmat Adam II, 152:(1)). Some contemporary poskim instruct to make Ha’adama on hydroponic vegetables (Shevet Halevi I:205), even if hydroponics is common, as long as society views it as grown on the ground (Teshuvot V’hanhagot II:149). Others rule to make Mezonot for bread and Shehakol for vegetables (Machazeh Eliyahu I:25,28; Yechaveh Da’at VI:12 views hydroponics as "worse" than ashn). They reason that not only do these berachot not mention land but they are also b’di’eved catch-all berachot making them preferable due to safek berachot l’hakel (in doubt, we avoid berachot that could be l’vatala). Still, Yechaveh Da’at (ibid.) says that if one does not know how a given vegetable was grown, you assume it is from the majority of vegetables, which are grown in the ground. Also, he says that if one made Ha’adama on a hydroponic vegetable, he would not say Shehakol afterward (as safek berachot l’hakel encourages us here to rely on the beracha that was already made). While we do not take a strong stand, we note that "pri ha’adama" seems a fair description of hydroponic vegetables, even if "min ha’aretz" ( from the land) is not for such bread (Teshuvot V’hanhagot ibid.)

Bemare Habazak - Rabbis Questions (626)

Rabbi Daniel Mann

613 - Ask the Rabbi: Amen on a Non-Beracha

614 - Ask the Rabbi: Halachic Status of Hydroponic Maror

615 - Ask the Rabbi: Indirect Responsibility for Theft

There is little question regarding Pesach. The lettuce’s maror status is determined by its qualities; its origin is, at best, relevant for the language of the beracha (Cheshev Ha’efod III:9). Indeed, the gemara (Pesachim 35b) alludes to kosher matza coming from grain grown in an ashn. It is conceivable to eat it and recite "al achilat matza," followed by "Mezonot" (Tzitz Eliezer IX:12). That paradox does not usually arise for maror, which does not get a birkat hanehenin, since it is eaten as part of the "meal" (a slight oversimplification – see Living the Halachic Process V, D-14). If one has hydroponic maror and no matza, he should follow his normal p’sak for the birkat hanehenin, followed by the beracha on maror.

Bemare Habazak - Rabbis Questions