- Shabbat and Holidays
- Peninei Halkha - Hanukkah
Chapter 13: When and Where to Light Hanuka Candles
6. Delaying Candle-Lighting When Necessary
If one finds it difficult to return home by tzeit, he may light later. One should try to return home as soon as possible, in order to light close to the ideal time ordained by the Sages.
As we have seen, in the time of the Sages people generally returned home at nightfall. Therefore, the Sages stated that the mitzva to light Ĥanuka candles extends "from sunset until the marketplace empties out." The expression "until the marketplace empties out" refers to the time when the poor people who would collect leftover food from the market stalls would return to their homes (Shabbat 21b). This was about half an hour after lighting time (Rif).
Nowadays, when there is electric lighting and most people continue working for several hours after dark, the best time to light is still the time that the Sages ordained – from tzeit until half an hour afterward. However, if one finds it difficult to return home by tzeit, he may light later. One should try to return home as soon as possible, in order to light close to the ideal time ordained by the Sages. Specifically, one should make an effort not to light later than 9 PM. Until then, it is standard for people to come home from work, so this period of the evening is still considered "until the marketplace empties out" (see n. 13 below). One should make sure not to eat a meal, meaning a keveitza of bread or mezonot, until after lighting (MB 672:10 and 431:6; above 12:13).
In some synagogues, a regular Torah class takes place following Ma’ariv, and if people leave to light candles after Ma’ariv, the class will be canceled. In such a case, it is preferable to hold the class as usual, and the attendees should light Ĥanuka candles afterward, because the mitzva of Torah study takes precedence over the value of lighting candles at the ideal time (see n. 13).
Nowadays, when there is electric lighting and most people continue working for several hours after dark, the best time to light is still the time that the Sages ordained – from tzeit until half an hour afterward. However, if one finds it difficult to return home by tzeit, he may light later. One should try to return home as soon as possible, in order to light close to the ideal time ordained by the Sages. Specifically, one should make an effort not to light later than 9 PM. Until then, it is standard for people to come home from work, so this period of the evening is still considered "until the marketplace empties out" (see n. 13 below). One should make sure not to eat a meal, meaning a keveitza of bread or mezonot, until after lighting (MB 672:10 and 431:6; above 12:13).
In some synagogues, a regular Torah class takes place following Ma’ariv, and if people leave to light candles after Ma’ariv, the class will be canceled. In such a case, it is preferable to hold the class as usual, and the attendees should light Ĥanuka candles afterward, because the mitzva of Torah study takes precedence over the value of lighting candles at the ideal time (see n. 13).
15. Candle Lighting at Public Gatherings
Chapter 12: Lighting the Hanuka Candles
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | Kislev 10 5782
4. The Proper Time and Duration of Lighting
Chapter 13: When and Where to Light Hanuka Candles
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | Kislev 10 5782
7. Waiting for a Family Member
Chapter 13: When and Where to Light Hanuka Candles
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | Kislev 12 5782
7. Adding a New Candle on Each Day of Hanuka
Chapter 11: Hanuka
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | Cheshvan 29 5782
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed
Rosh Yeshiva of Har Bracha and rabbi of the settlement.
The Mourner’s Kaddish
Chapter four-part two
Preparations for Prayer
Chapter five-part one
5775
11. The Prohibition on Women Doing Work
Chapter 11: Hanuka
Kislev 4 5782
The chazan
Chapter four-part one
5775
Who Can Be Counted in a Minyan?
Chapter Two-part three
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed

Chanuka Candles and Havdala – Which Comes First?
Rabbi Daniel Mann | 5775

How Does a Person Convert to Judaism?
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff

Some Light Chanukah Questions
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | 20 kislev 5769
Judging Favorably – Even the Good Ones
Rabbi Zalman Baruch Melamed | 11 Kislev 5784

Parashat Vayetse- The Character of Jacob
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks | Kislev 11 5784

How the Four Places Called "Zion" are All the Same
Rabbi Moshe Tzuriel | 4 Kislev 5784
