Ask the Rabbi

  • Family and Society
  • Mezuza

House with a Mezuza

undefined

Rabbi David Sperling

Tishrei 24, 5783
Question
We purchased a house and the original owners were Jewish and they left the Mezuza case outside the front door. I would like to keep it because I, a catholic, have much respect for Jews. I feel that if I remove it, it would be disrespectful. Linda
Answer
Shalom, Thank you for your question. Let me start by expressing my joy at reading your query. It is so nice to see people of different religions respecting the Jewish people, and wanting to do act in a way that shows that respect – and even more by going to the trouble to reach out to a Rabbi to find out how Jewish people would view such an act. A sincere thank you. A major tenant of Judaism is that we believe not all mankind needs to serve G-d in the same way. We believe that the Jewish people have a particular obligation to follow the laws laid out for us. In general, when we see non-Jews using particularly Jewish objects of worship – whether it be a Mezuzah, our ritual garments (Tallit and Tzitzit), etc – most religious Jews feel uncomfortable. Even though your intention is certainly a good one, and you want to show your respect for the Jewish people – by appropriating our special service and symbols, we tend to feel that these items lose their holiness when they become disconnected from their being expressions of a Jew for filling their faith. So, with this in mind, it would be a greater act of respect if you were to remove the Mezuzah. Due to the holiness of the Mezuzah itself, it would be best if you could find a local Rabbi who you could pass it on to. (If not, then wrap it up well, and put it aside until you have a chance to give it to a religious Jew who will know what to do with it). There are though, many ways you can show your respect for the Jewish people. The first is to speak out against any forms of antisemitism, or anti-Israel, you come across. Together with encouraging all to follow (what I believe is the current teachings of the Catholic Church) a love for the Jewish people, and an understanding that we are a unique and true expression of G-d’s revelation in the world. We would love to see you and you family (and you congregation!) visit the holy land of Israel - May you be blessed with only good.
את המידע הדפסתי באמצעות אתר yeshiva.org.il