Yavneh and its Scholars

Based on Siach Shaul, Pirkei Machshava V’Hadracha p. 803 (address to students)

undefined
Vayishlach, Kislev 18, 5787
It is not by chance that R. Yochanan ben Zakai chose Yavneh and its scholars [to ask the Romans to spare] (Gittin 56b). We find a beautiful statement in the name of these scholars. “I am a creation, and my friend is a creation. My work is in the city, and his work is in the field. I wake up early to tend to my work, and he wakes up early to tend to his work. Just like he is not encroaching on my work, so I am not encroaching on his work. Maybe you will say that I accomplish a lot and he accomplishes little? We have learned: It is the same whether one accomplishes a lot or a little, as long as his heart is focused on the Heaven” (Berachot 17a). This is the approach of a scholar who meshes himself within the nation as a whole, and does not see himself as one whose role provides him with greater rights. Rather it obligates him to act on behalf of the community in the realms in which he is uniquely qualified. This idea contrasts with what we saw in Chazal’s account of the destruction of the Temple. It discussed the timidness of Zecharia ben Avkilas [who did not intervene when one Jew publicly shamed another]. His silence was the cause of the horrible dispute between brethren. It was probably due to an assumption that whatever happens in the world does not concern a scholar. “We are men of Torah and have a special standing. Our only concern is our success in ensuring that our personal space is not broached.” The scholars of Yavneh were great in Torah, but they also knew that their learning was not for their own sake (see Sanhedrin 99b). They knew that “I am a creation, and my friend is a creation.” In other words, everyone has a role, and every role is important. While “fortunate is one whose profession deals with fragrances” (Pesachim 65a), on the other hand, “the world cannot exist without tanners” (ibid.). From this perspective, we cannot estimate who is more important, as each is needed. This might be the intention of the first blessing on Torah reading, which stresses the choice of Israel and the giving of the Torah to it. This means that there is something above the choice in every Jew – the power of being special. The role of being involved in Torah is not of creating something out of nothing, but revealing that which exists under the pile of emptiness. If so, normal living comes before display of being Israeli, of self-sacrifice for the nation, of a desire for a pure life full of holy seriousness. Yet, there is an important rule that there can be no success without striving for “eternal life.” The expressions of justice and rectitude do not on their own give power to eternal life – their power is only in the realm of normal life. This combination is not simple. It costs a lot of life blood. One has to think a lot and exert himself even more in order to not get ensnared in the trap of extremism. Some see this as spiritual ambiguity – not here and not there. Some see it as feebleness, from a desire to make due with what exists rather than fight. This is not the case. Hillel’s characteristic of not getting angry at people (Shabbat 31a) was not a convenient strategy. His calmness sometimes caused others to complain, but Hillel kept to it anyway. It was not convenience, but belief in the path. Our community’s approach is not because it is more comfortable. Often, perhaps usually, it is more difficult. It is not a compromise; it is an act of combining the good found in everyone. It is putting stress on eternal life, yet not forgetting that normal life is not bereft of content. Rather, everything comes from a source of sanctity and returns to that source. I understand that all of you who have sat together in class will disperse and that every single one of you will have challenges. We learned in Mesillat Yesharim that it is an illusion to think there can be life without challenges. They will appear in the more natural life and the more spiritual life. Your job is to hold the line!
Popular Lessons
Popular Lessons
Recent Lessons
Recent Lessons
את המידע הדפסתי באמצעות אתר yeshiva.org.il