Beit Midrash
  • Family and Society
  • The Land of Israel
קטגוריה משנית

RAMBAM AGAINST ALIYA?!" What is his opinion on Living in Israel?

Some claim the Rambam says one shouldn't make Aliya and live in Israel (the Megilat-Esther's understanding), which is often used as an excuse not to "make the move". This short but encompassing article brings many places in the Mishneh Torah where the Rambam clarifies his own opinion.

undefined
Kislev 12, 5787
Q. A popular claim holds that the Rambam opposed aliyah – is that really what he wrote? A. I’m sorry but you are grossly misinformed. Only R. Yitzchak deLeon (in his commentary called “Megilat Esther” on the Ramban’s Sefer Mitzvot, addition 4), who is not considered by any accounts a posek, suggests that MAYBE (!) the reason the Rambam doesn’t count mitzvat yishuv haAretz (living in Israel) as one of the 613 mitzvot is because it’s not applicable during galut (and the Rambam only counts mitzvot which apply in all times, Sefer HaMitzvot, shoresh 3). This approach is only one of many different explanations suggested, but is soundly REJECTED by almost everyone for the following reasons: The Rambam himself in hil. Avadim (8, 9), takes the trouble to explicitly state that the mitzvah to live in Eretz Yisrael is in all generations, also during galut, even if the Land is in the hands of the gentiles! Additionally, in hil. Mlachim (5, 12), the Rambam says explicitly “a person should ALWAYS live in Eretz Yisrael, even in a city of gentiles, and not in chu”l even in a Jewish city”. The Rambam could have sufficed with his opening statement (“a person should always live in Eretz Yisrael), yet again he goes out of his way to give an example (“even in a city of gentiles, and not in chu”l even in a Jewish city”, clearly referring to the period of galut), where we (or the Megilat Esther!) may have thought otherwise! Another unquestionable proof regarding the Rambam’s opinion is in hil. Mlachim (7, 14), that the p’tur (exemption) from the Israeli army (not in the IDF's defensive wars but in milchemet r’shut- an optional/offensive war) for one who planted a vineyard (and didn’t redeem it in the fourth year) or one who built a house (and has yet to dedicate it) is only if they are in Eretz Yisrael. As usual, the Rambam takes his halachot straight from the Talmudic sources, in this case from the Talmud Yerushalmi (Sotah 8, 4), which explains the reason is because only in ER.Y. is planting a vine and building a house a mitzva, that of settling ErY. This exemption from the army is a halacha m’doraita (Torah-level mitzva), and there is no other way to explain the Rambam, but that he clearly holds mitzvat yishuv ErY is a mitzvah d’oraita, in other words, in all generations. I personally think that it is not kavod (respectful) to R. Yitzchak deLeon even to quote his understanding of the Rambam, which he clearly did not check up throughout the Mishneh Torah (give him the benefit of the doubt, for there were no computers searches then!), where the Rambam’s consistent opinion is that it’s a mitzva D’oraita in all times, explicitly contradicting R. DeLeon's suggested explanation of the Rambam. [Ironically, today with the advent of the State of Israel, even R. DeLeon who was often cited as the opinion who justifies living in chu”l, apparently holds that the mitzvah has returned! For he opines that according to the Rambam there is no mitzvah until the Land is in our hands (“when we are not subjected to non-Jewish rule”). And as the Rambam himself writes, hil. Tshuva (9, 2); Milachim (12, 2), we know we are in the period of mashiach if we have an independent state, and we’re not under foreign rule. In other words, today, even the "Megilat Esther" would agree, for even if the Mashiach has yet to come, we are already in what the Rambam terms (ibid) y’mot haMashiach, “the days of Mashiach”!]. A much more accepted explanation why the Rambam omits living in Israel from his list of 613, is that of the Chatam Sofer (Resp. ii, YD 234) who explains that the Rambam holds that the mitzvah to live in Israel is because of the inherent and all-encompassing Kedusha here (in the fruits, air & even in the sand & rocks, Rambam, Mlachim 5, 10). Accordingly, the Rambam, who as we saw says that one should always live in Israel, holds that it's not "JUST" one mitzvah, but something much MORE basic and comprehensive! Although for those living in America, R. deLeon is obviously popular, it is clearly wrong (something I would never dare say about any opinion of a rishon on any issue, but the Megilat Esther can hardly be considered a halachic authority, surely not a rishon- there is not even one (!) halacha in his name brought in the entire Shulchan Aruch, and not everyone who lived in the period of rishonim has that status). As we saw, the misunderstanding of the "Megilat Esther" is self-evident throughout the Mishneh Torah, where maybe he can say that it's his opinion, but there's no way he can say it in the name of the Rambam who writes to the contrary! Also, we pasken halacha from the Shulchan Aruch who, like the Rambam, says that living in Israel is a mitzvah today (OrCh 248, 4) and in all times, and not like R. deLeon. I apologize if someone thought he could actually use R. deLeon as an excuse not to make Aliya, but it wouldn't be intellectually honest to contradict the much more accepted Chatam Sofer, an acclaimed "heavyweight" posek, especially when the Rambam himself contradicts R. deLeon explanation of the Rambam! Shabbat Shalom! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)
Popular Lessons
Popular Lessons
Recent Lessons
Recent Lessons
את המידע הדפסתי באמצעות אתר yeshiva.org.il