Ask the Rabbi
- Torah and Jewish Thought
- Torah Study
- General Questions
Question
Why, if the kingship is in Yehudah, did Shmuel pick Shaul who was from Binyamin?
Answer
The Ramban explains that in the source itself that the kingdom belongs to Judah, the wording is "The (ruler's) staff shall not leave (!) Judah" (Breishit 49, 10), that once kingship comes to Yehudah it should not be taken away. On the other hand, Shaul was appointed by God Himself (through his prophet Shmuel, who was directed to anoint him), despite coming from the tribe of Benjamin, because the kingship is not "leaving" or being "taken away" from Judah, for David had not yet received it.

Mishneh Torah study
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Shevat 13, 5774

The Sadducees
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Tammuz 17, 5780

Becoming a rabbi
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Tishrei 13, 5786





