- Sections
- Parashat Hashavua
A Holy Soldier?
"When you go out as a camp against your enemy, you shall be careful about all bad things" (Devarim 23:10). The Torah goes on to discuss regulations of purity and of hygiene and explains, "For Hashem, your G-d, is going in the midst of your camp to save you and to hand your enemy over to you, and your camp shall be holy, and He shall not see in you an unseemly thing and abandon you" (ibid. 15).
Judaism does not mandate any action that justifies the breaking of boundaries of basic order. To the contrary, the more important a course of action is the more care must be taken to do it in a way that it is not dirtied or spoiled. If the enemy’s army camps are a place where anything goes and semblances of humanity disappear, the Torah way is that our camp must be a holy one. "A soldier" and "holy"? In today’s mind-set, the sound of the two together is strange. However, that is only because the general mind-set is so far from the concepts of the Torah.
The whole concept of war is a different one for us. For the nations, it is a time of wholesale murder, without rules or a search to justify one’s actions. An outburst of the animal within a person, of the basest instincts, is considered a good thing for them. That way the wild soldier can act with greater cruelty and less thought. Judaism does not allow murder. For us, war is designed to fight those who have already lost human dignity, so that their destruction is a removal of evil. This mitzva must be done in a way that uses no less holiness and purity than any other mitzva.
"He who is afraid and is of a soft heart," who is sent back from the camp (Devarim 20:8), is referring to one who is afraid due to sins of which he is guilty (Sota 8:5). It is possible that there is no such concept among the nations of the world. Perhaps it is to the contrary for them, one who breaks through boundaries may be stronger and braver than others. However, this is not the case for Israel. We are nourished by our connection to Hashem, and one who sins severs this connection, which causes him to be afraid. The apparent bravery that he might display comes from fear, and it can be the trigger to his subsequent fleeing from the battle. It is only the bravery of those who already have nothing to lose.
Judaism does not mandate any action that justifies the breaking of boundaries of basic order. To the contrary, the more important a course of action is the more care must be taken to do it in a way that it is not dirtied or spoiled. If the enemy’s army camps are a place where anything goes and semblances of humanity disappear, the Torah way is that our camp must be a holy one. "A soldier" and "holy"? In today’s mind-set, the sound of the two together is strange. However, that is only because the general mind-set is so far from the concepts of the Torah.
The whole concept of war is a different one for us. For the nations, it is a time of wholesale murder, without rules or a search to justify one’s actions. An outburst of the animal within a person, of the basest instincts, is considered a good thing for them. That way the wild soldier can act with greater cruelty and less thought. Judaism does not allow murder. For us, war is designed to fight those who have already lost human dignity, so that their destruction is a removal of evil. This mitzva must be done in a way that uses no less holiness and purity than any other mitzva.
"He who is afraid and is of a soft heart," who is sent back from the camp (Devarim 20:8), is referring to one who is afraid due to sins of which he is guilty (Sota 8:5). It is possible that there is no such concept among the nations of the world. Perhaps it is to the contrary for them, one who breaks through boundaries may be stronger and braver than others. However, this is not the case for Israel. We are nourished by our connection to Hashem, and one who sins severs this connection, which causes him to be afraid. The apparent bravery that he might display comes from fear, and it can be the trigger to his subsequent fleeing from the battle. It is only the bravery of those who already have nothing to lose.

If Like Sons, If Like Servants
Rabbi Shaul Yisraeli zt"l | 25 Elul 5783

Present or Inheritance... or Both?
Various Rabbis | Tevet 5768

He Did not Look at Iniquity in Jacob
Rabbi Yossef Carmel | Tammuz 5783

Parashat Hashavua: Publicizing those who Perform Mitzvot
Rabbi Yossef Carmel | 13 Elul 5783

Rabbi Shaul Yisraeli zt"l
Rosh Yeshiva of "Mercaz Harav", Rosh Kollel of "Eretz Hemda" and a member of Beit Din Hagadol in Yerushalaim.

Listening for Listening’s Sake
Av 22 5777

Holy of Holies
Iyar 2 5776

Caring about Justice for All
Shvat 14 5776

The Place of Tumah in the Human Experience
based on Siach Shaul, pg. 328-330
Iyar 5773

Showering on Shabbat
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff
Iron Swords: The War Against Hamas, 5784 (2023)
Rabbi Zalman Baruch Melamed | 26 Cheshvan 5784

Showering on Shabbat
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff

Explaining the Mitzvah of Pidyon Shevuyim
The Commandment of Redeeming Captives
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff

Orot HaMilchama part IV- Wars & Selflessness- Part of the Process of Geula
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Kislev 7 5784

Competition and the Lonely Road to Heaven
Rabbi Haggai Lundin | 18 Kislev 5784

Our Brothers - The Entire House of Israel
Rabbi Yaakov Asher Sinclair | Kislev 4 5784
