- Torah and Jewish Thought
- General Questions
Positive and negative Mitzvot
Question
I can’t remember the source (please let me know), but I’ve heard that the reason why there are doubles of a negative and positive mitzvah for doing or not doing the same action is that Hashem wants to add to our Schar, but I don’t understand how that works. Let’s take the example of Tzidaka. There’s a positive Mitzvah to give and a negative mitzvah to not withhold. If you give, you get reward for the positive Mitzvah. If you withhold, you get punished for violating the negative and you also get punished for the Bitul Ahsay. So it seems like it can only work against you? (other examples are chilul Hashem/kiddush Hashem, and listen to the Gedolim/lo Tasur)
Answer
There is a verse in Kohelet (7:14) which states "zeh le'umat zeh asah Elokim", meaning that G-d made things and their opposites or counterparts. Rashi there explains that G-d made the good and its reward and the bad and its compensation.
Chazal in many places (See Vayikra Rabba 34, Psikta D'rav Kahana 28) made this verse into a concept saying that G-d made the rich and the poor so that they both benefit each other; the rich giving the poor and the poor, though not by will, creating the opportunity for the rich to benefit them.
In addition, Chazal, also in many places (See for example Baba Metzia 70b) have the concept that the Torah added a positive mitzvah to an already existing negative mitzvah. Though as you correctly said there is the downside of transgressing two mitzvoth at once and being punished for it, there is the upside of getting rewarded for the abstaining from sin and in addition getting rewarded for fulfilling a mitzvah.

Unity- prophecy about tree of Judah and israel
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Tammuz 11, 5774

The Blessing of keeping The Laws of Niddah
Various Rabbis | 15 Cheshvan 5763

What is happening to me?
Various Rabbis | 4 Cheshvan 5763

Reading books like harry potter and the chronicles of narnia
Various Rabbis | Adar I 5, 5771

Rabbi Yoel Lieberman

Wedding in shloshim
Elul 20, 5769

Jewish Learning
Av 27, 5769

is a cruise ship considered its own domain
Elul 4, 5769

Human skull in office
Elul 6, 5769

Kashrus - dvar charif
Rabbi David Sperling | Av 7, 5774

Mikvah for unmarried women
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | 16 Tevet 5766

Shehakol on Fruit and Vegetable Juices?
Torah & Land Institution | 2 Adar II 5763

Omer Days I can shave/cut hair
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 2, 5774
halachas
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Iyyar 21, 5782

negiah with niece - level of prohibition
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 21, 5782
