Ask the Rabbi
- Torah and Jewish Thought
- Emuna - Jewish Thought
- General Questions
Question
Shaom Rabbi,
I saw a few books mentioning Shedim (demons) and even the Gemara mentions them. I always thought that demons was a primitive superstition but then, it seems our sages believed in them! Maybe I have a misunderstanding of what Shedim are
Thanks
Answer
Shalom! There are many things in life beyond that which is seen by the naked eye, and among them are what we call malachim (angels) and sheidim (negative angels). As opposed to other religions, Judaism believes that they have no free-will, are not independent, and are just robot-like messengers doing the will of God. This can include germs, viruses etc..
The Talmud mentions beings called sheidim, but also states, โone who worries about them- they bother him, while he who doesnโt worry about them, they donโt bother himโ (Psachim 110b). Similarly, among the rishonim there are different opinions.
The Rashba, for example, talks about them but the Rambam whenever he must, explains the concept in rational terms (e.g. Hil. Rotzeโach 12, 5). Nevertheless, all agree that man and God, and no other forces, run our lives. Only we and God have free will, and accordingly weโre not allowed to believe in superstitions or the like. Many point out that certain powers that may have existed, arenโt found any more today in our countries (e.g. Magen Avraham 173, 1), and Rav Kook adds from the kabbalists that in the Holy Land of Israel, all the more so, that one need not worry about sheidim.
With Love of Israel,
Rav Ari Shvat

Why does love sometimes hurt?
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Cheshvan 2, 5782

Jews and Non-Jews
Rabbi Chaim Tabasky | 6 Cheshvan 5765

Hishtadlut - how much is right & the Purim Story
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Adar II 12, 5782




