Beit Midrash
  • Torah Portion and Tanach
  • Torah Portion
  • D'varim
קטגוריה משנית
undefined
Every year, as the Tisha B'Av mode begins, Jews in America "remember" to yearn for the Geula, which unfortunately usually doesn't preoccupy them unless searching for a "siyum" in order to eat meat and alleviate their mourning. Contrarily in Israel every time we listen to the daily news and go to milu'im or our shelters, we are dealing with the challenges of the "the birthpains of mashiach". We read in p. Dvarim that despite many super-natural miracles in the exodus and subsequently in the desert, still many Jews were skeptical and scared to come on Aliyah (1, 22-27). The "FEAR OF THE UNKOWN" is usually well-grounded in reality, for any change, even one for the better, is challenging. Even in the times of Moshe, it wasn't easy and smoothe, for the giants Sichon and Og were real, and the impending end of the pillar of fire and cloud, manna and miraculous water, awakened us to the realities of having to work for a living and serve in the Israeli army. Yes, then and today, even though G-d is on our side, that doesn't mean the challenges aren't real and must be overcome. Even as we live redemption, this time of year we must take stock of what Hashem has already redeemed, and what we still lack and need to implore of Him, e.g. peace, the Sanhedrin & Beit HaMidash. Contrarily the "all or nothing" Jews supposedly relate to a dreamy Geula where everything is going to suddenly be "peaches and cream". They focus on MR. Mashiach rather than on the Geula PROCESS. Interestingly, even after the Balfour Declaration, the skeptics said: "We still don't have a Jewish State". Even after achieving the State of Israel, they complained: how can this be the process of redemption if "we still lack Y'rushalayim?". Even after liberating the Holy City, they kvetch: "but most of the Jews are still in galut". As that excuse is also ending, they alibi, "but Israel isn't as religious as we'd like". As statistically that excuse is also running out, they focus even more on Mr. Mashiach, and refuse to participate until he himself comes (which unfortunately is going to be only the final stage of redemption, Megilla 17b). We notice an interesting phenomenon: One would have thought that those Geula-denyers would be even more preoccupied on a daily basis on how they think we are in galut as much as we were during the Crusades and Holocaust, and they would cry day and night for redemption, as we did then. But we see to the contrary, we who recognize the Geula process and have already seen most of the prophecies of redemption fulfilled, we are more preoccupied with what we still lack, for we take the redemption seriously. It turns out that those who attempt to hasten redemption really feel the few things that we still lack and pray and work to achieve them, while the naïve dreamers who lack even more, don't really relate to Geula as something real, but pay "lip-service" when the Shulchan Aruch or calendar offers no choice (except for that meaty siyum!). The Netziv stresses that G-d told the kvetching Moshe, "DON'T TELL ME HOW TO RUN MY REDEMPTION!", and adds that this message is for modern anti-Zionists, as well (Shmot 4, 13 and Shivat Tzion, p. 17!. If one really believes in Geula, he would grab every glimmer of hope available, rather than ignoring what G-d has already granted us, kvetching that it's "all or nothing". That yearning for instant gratification was always seen in Judaism as a problem, and surely not an ideal. The Talmud teaches that the 2nd Mikdash was destroyed either because of Sinat Chinam (needless hate) or because most of the Jews from Bavel didn't come on Aliyah with Ezra (Yoma 9b), where the common denominator between the two, is clearly: a lack of unity. Yes, we must improve our Ahavat Chinam, but the half million orthodox Jews still stuck in the sin of their Babylonian predecessors, should FOCUS at least as much on fixing that more EASILY DEFINED shortcoming and make Aliyah. Like the inevitable "cold feet" before one's wedding, we must encourage the bride or groom not to "fear the unknown". This Tisha b'Av, let's beg Hashem to help us achieve that which we still lack, while encouraging our brothers who are still "stuck" on the previous stages of redemption, to overcome the architecture of alibis, and join Am Yisrael. The Rambam stresses the Torah's definition of redemption is Kibbutz Galuyot (Hil. Milachim 11, 1 based on Dvarim 30, 3-4), and anyone who really wants and believes in it will see it and participate, thus fixing the Cheit HaMeraglim and that 2nd reason for Churban, while the rest of us can already focus on the upcoming stages.
Popular Lessons
Popular Lessons
Recent Lessons
Recent Lessons
את המידע הדפסתי באמצעות אתר yeshiva.org.il