Ask the Rabbi
- Family and Society
- The Jewish Household
- Family Purity
Question
Hello.
I would like to clarify some details. It is well known that Rambam is often pasken like Yerushalmi and not like Bavli.
But in his “Isurei Biah” 10:9 about what is “tzuras adam” Rambam quote rabbi Yochonon from Bavli (Niddah,23b) but in Yerushalmi there is opposite opinion in name of rabbi Yochonon.
So why (and how) did Rambam pasken not like Yerushalmi in this case?
Answer
In general the Rambam paskens like the Babvli except for special cases such as a case that the Bavli doesn't pasken and remains in a safek and the Yerushalmi decides the halacha without a doubt (see Shach Yoreh deah 145; 1). My friend and former chavruta Harav Achikam Kashat brought different sources about this. See his article here
All the best!
Hearing aid follow up
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Nisan 22, 5784

Feedback beeping in hearing aids on shabbas
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Nisan 10, 5784





