- Shabbat and Holidays
- Megilla Reading
Reading Megillah for others when advised by doctor not to
Question
If a person read the Megillah in shul and the doctor told him he should not read the Megillah it’s dangerous for him... After Purim, he went to the doctor and the doctor told him nothing happened then it was totally fine that he read the megillah... Did he get a Mitzvah and were the people in the shul Yotzei the megillah?
Answer
לז"נ יונה שלמה ב"ר אברהם יוסף ז"ל
Shalom, ב"ה
The facts you presented are somewhat conflicting. On the one hand you said the doctor said reading the Megilla was dangerous and then you quote the same doctor who said doing so was fine.
So, I will simply mention in short the classic example of one who was ordered by his doctor not to fast on Yom Kippur and fasted in any case, not only did he not commit a mitzvah but an aveira.(שו"ת מהר"ם שיק סי' רס, Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchata Ch. 39: 2 ) and it is as if he spilled his own blood .( שו"ת הרדב"ז ח"ג סי' תמד ואו"ה סי' ס סע' ח.). The Mishna Brura, (שו"ע או"ח תריח מ"ב ה). brings the poskim who say " ..the blood of your own lives I will demand an account"(בראשית ט:ה).
As far as being Yotzei , the Bracha on the megilla, I wouldn't want to be the one give a ruling on this, especially from what you described the doctor went back on his own medical recommendation.
But the closest case I found is in a question relevant to our upcoming Pessach. The Maharam Shik,(1807-1879) (שו"ת מהר"ם שיק סי' רס) was asked in regard to a person for whom eating Maror or Matzah is a medical danger, if he may eat the Matzah and make a Bracha on it, and he ruled that he may not eat it nor make the Bracha.
I just, wish to add, that I planned to answer you yesterday but I was delayed. And I must say, that the delay was for the better, because I came across this important Maharam Shik.
All the best.
Have a happy and kosher Pessach.

to listen to the doctor
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Adar II 29, 5779

Megilla Through Loudspeakers
Rabbi Chaim Tabasky | 1 Iyyar 5765

Megillah reading
Various Rabbis | 7 Adar 5766

Spliting the Megillah reading
Various Rabbis | Adar I 15, 5768

Rabbi Yoel Lieberman

Friday Night
Av 26, 5769

L’Dovid Hashem Ori
Elul 11, 5769

Swimming together with siblings
Av 29, 5769

Bilam
Elul 20, 5769
Genesis 24: 2-9 – Put your hand under my thigh
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Tevet 26, 5770

non-Jewish cooking
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 27, 5773

Drinking on Simchas Torah
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | 21 Tishrei 5766

No sukkah at home
Rabbi David Sperling | Tishrei 7, 5775

chelev oblation
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Elul 25, 5783
hagomel in Yom kipur
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Tishrei 9, 5784
