- Sections
- P'ninat Mishpat
30
Case: The plaintiff (=pl) served as a rosh kollel for the defendant (=def), an organization. For several years, def paid pl with a kollel stipend rather than a worker’s salary with a wage stub and social benefits. Then, def started paying pl, based on pl’s request, as a worker. Pl, who quit a year later, now demands to have his social benefits rights restored retroactively. Def argues that pl was indeed a kollel student, who received a higher than normal stipend because he also did some teaching. Def also argues that pl agreed to the conditions, which are totally standard for roshei kollel in Israel.

P'ninat Mishpat (777)
Various Rabbis
539 - Dissolution of Real Estate Joint Ownership after Divorce
540 - Waiving Workers’ Benefits
541 - Firing a Contractor – part I
Load More
A worker can relinquish rights when they are based on common practice, but not when they are based on the law of the land. In truth, some poskim enable agreement to overcome the law in matters of employment, claiming that the law is based on "values that are foreign to the Torah," rather than improvement of society. Also, some argue that since agreement overcomes Torah law in monetary matters, it certainly overcomes rights given by the law of the land. However, beit din followed the approach that basic workers’ rights are not just a matter that impacts individuals but the face of the workplace, making the law of the land viable. Based on the principles, beit din awarded pension contributions, severance pay, and recreation pay, and required def to retroactively provide wage stubs.
Appeal: If we follow the law of the land even when it is not common practice, beit din is no different than secular courts. In the realm of Torah institutions, the determinants of who is a worker do not apply, and general judicial precedent is thus irrelevant. Pl worked elsewhere and also did personal learning in his first years in the kollel, so that at least some of his pay should be a stipend.
Appeal Ruling: The beit din ruling is based on the Rashba and the Rama (Choshen Mishpat 369:11) that the laws of the land apply to laws done to improve society as a whole. According to this, matters of the public, including the protection of workers, who are the "weaker" members of society, exceed personal interests. When such laws begin, they are usually against common practice, but over time, as in this case, they become generally accepted by society. Therefore, in this case, the law is valid halachically. Use of the legal precedent just helps understand the law’s intention. It is not true that roshei kollel, as a rule, are not paid as workers.
Had pl accepted the pay offer without benefits with the intention to later sue, he would have been acting in bad faith and his claims should be dismissed. But there was no claim that this occurred. It does not make sense to break pl’s wages into a stipend part and a work part, as all was part of one set of responsibilities.

P'ninat Mishpat: How Far Does a Lien Go?
based on ruling 83097 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Shevat 5784

P'ninat Mishpat: What is Included in Costs of the Elevator?
based on ruling 82159 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Tishrei 5785

P'ninat Mishpat: Rent of an Apartment Without a Protected Room
based on ruling 84036 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Iyar 5784

P'ninat Mishpat: Did the Real Estate Agent Remain Relevant?
based on ruling 84031 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Adar 5784

Until One Hundred and Twenty
Rabbi Yosef Tzvi Rimon | 5778

Why is Hafrashat Challah So Important
Rabbi Yosef Tzvi Rimon | 5778

Tasting Non-Kosher Wine
Various Rabbis | 5773

Until One Hundred and Twenty
Rabbi Yosef Tzvi Rimon | 5778

"FIND MY SPOUSE"- Kohanim Can also Help!
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Sivan 5785

The Land of Israel's Special Light, as Reflected in the Priestly Blessing
Rabbi Moshe Tzuriel | 10 Sivan 5785

"Bad Thoughts vs. Bad Deeds"
Ayn Aya Shabbat v, 80
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Sivan 5785
