- Family and Society
- War Ethics
Shalit Deal
Question
What does Jewish law say on the Shalit Deal - 1000 terrorists released for a Jewish soldier?
Answer
ב"ה
Shalom
The classic case of redeeming of a captive in the Talmud (Gitin 45a), is when a person was kidnapped for ransom. The Talmud forbids redeeming of captives for exorbitant amounts of money because of Tikun olam- the "betterment of the world", and the Talmud offers two reasons for this ordinance. One: if the kidnappers ask for too much, the community may not be able to withstand the financial burden. Two: If the too much is given, they may attempt to kidnap again.
Unfortunately, this was not a theoretical discussion. Rav Meir of Rothenberg zt"l was taken prisoner in Germany in the 13th century. The community mobilized an enormous sum of money, but he refused to be redeemed based upon the above Talmud and he eventually died in prison after seven years of incarceration.
Though the same principles apply, the reality in our time is much different from the time of the Talmud. It is soldier who was taken captive, who worked as an emissary for the people of Israel and for whom the State of Israel has a moral obligation to redeem. On the other hand, the captives did not ask for money, but for the release of murderers some of which after their release murdered again. There are strategic factors involved when it comes to national security and of course there may have been other factors which were never made public.
Therefore, at the time there was no uniform opinion on the issue and there were many Rabbis who strongly opposed the deal.
May Hashem watch and keep over us and to save the Jewish people from such dilemmas.
All the best

War and Urim VeTumim
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Iyyar 15, 5781
Commander’s orders vs. Halacha
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Shevat 21, 5772

killing innocent gentiles in Tanach
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Nisan 6, 5775

Serving under non-religious commanders in Israeli army
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Iyyar 14, 5781

Rabbi Yoel Lieberman

Modern laws vs Shulchan Orach
Av 28, 5769

Birkat Hamazon
Elul 5, 5769

Yerushalmi
Av 27, 5769

Ma’ariv Times
Elul 11, 5769

How to kosher a Barbeque Grill
Rabbi David Sperling | Sivan 11, 5776
Meaning of the name "Yaakov"
Rabbi Berel Wein | 2 Kislev 5763

Mezzuzah for Non Jew
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 18, 5773

Bracha on water
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | Cheshvan 16, 5769

Early Shabbat Candle Lighting
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Av 6, 5782

Preparation for Davening
Rabbi David Sperling | Av 7, 5782

Can an electric tea kettle be assumed to be kosher?
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Av 13, 5782
