- Torah and Jewish Thought
- Torah Teachings
Disregarding the Talmud
Question
The Talmud (Shabbat 56a) states "Whomever says (King) David sinned, is mistaken."
The Abarbanel (in the section of the book of Samuel dealing with King David’s "sin") writes: "I am one of the mistaken ones." And then proceeds to enumerate at least five transgressions of King David in the affair.
Is this acceptable, to just disregard the Talmud?
Answer
I reviewed the commentary of the Abarbanel on Shmuel II (Chapter 11) and I did not find that he said the words: " I am one of the mistaken ones." If he indeed said so it is only rhetoric which is characteristic to his time. Nonetheless,he does not disregard the Talmud. The Abarbanel finds the expounding of the Talmud difficult to reconcile with the simple verses in which David himself says "I have sinned." (Shmuel II, 12,13). He therefore chooses a different interpretation which is closer to the "pshat"=the simple understanding of the verse, in his opinion. He then also says that David did full repentance, was punished and was completely forgiven by G-d.
Rashi in many places juxtaposes the "pshat" with the "drash" and in fact places his understanding of the "pshat" before the "drash" of the Rabbis in the Talmud. (See for example Rashi Beraishit 37:2) This in no way is disregarding of Chazal. However it is method of commentary employed by many commentators of the Tanach.

Guns as Kli Gever
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Elul 11, 5768

The Meaning of the Abbreviation "Shlita"
Various Rabbis | 25 Tammuz 5765
Homosexuality for gentiles
Rabbi Gideon Weitzman | 6 Nisan 5766

Question about Parashat Emor
Rabbi David Sperling | Adar I 9, 5782

Rabbi Yoel Lieberman

Friday Night
Av 26, 5769

L’Dovid Hashem Ori
Elul 11, 5769

Kashrut
Elul 14, 5769

Golden altar of Incense
Elul 14, 5769

No-wedding days
Rabbi David Sperling | Sivan 20, 5772

Kashering a dishwasher
Rabbi David Sperling | Cheshvan 23, 5778

Shehakol on Fruit and Vegetable Juices?
Torah & Land Institution | 2 Adar II 5763

The Meaning of the Abbreviation "Shlita"
Various Rabbis | 25 Tammuz 5765

About Olam
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Iyyar 21, 5782

a mishna
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 16, 5782

Noahides
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Iyyar 25, 5782
