- Family and Society
- Settling the Land of Israel
Eretz Yisrael vs Torah
Question
If a man living in Israel would learn less torah than if he lived in Chutz La’aretz would he be permitted to live in Eretz Yisrael?
a] Would he be permitted to reside permanently in Chutz la’arez?
b] What are rav Kook’s views on the matter?
Answer
I have discussed this matter in the past with Rav David Samson, a close student of Rav Kook (the son) and a world wide known authority on Rav Kooks' (the father) writings.
He quoted several Gedolim including the Chafetz Chaim that held very clearly that one can not make Hashems' "book keeping".
We are servents and as such we do what we wre told, the Torah includes a Mitzvah to live in Israel and you have no right to avoid fulfilling this Mitzvah for imaginary personal excuses.
You do your part of the deal – the Mitzvah to study and Hashem will take care if his part of the deal and allow you to grow in Torah.
Similarly you have no guarantee you will study Torah outside of Israel and not in Israel, the title Eretz Ysrael vs. Torah is deceitful.
It is true that if you have a specific rabbi or Yeshiva you really want to study from and can't find your place in the Yeshivot in Eretz Yisrael – you have permission to leave, as the Rambam (Melachim 5:9) states, however then also only temporarily.

Return of Israel mentioned in Bible
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Tammuz 7, 5775

The Chalutzim and life-threatening danger
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Sivan 10, 5781

Visiting Negev
Various Rabbis | 12 Tammuz 5764

The Land of Israel is Ours
Rabbi David Samson | 14 Elul 5762

Rabbi Elchanan Lewis
Former Rabbi of Jewish congregation in Perth, Australia

Shiva for Gentile Relatives
18 Tammuz 5764

Old-New Testament
9 Tammuz 5764

Davening for someone who is sick
13 Tammuz 5764

Cohanim Staying in a Car
17 Tammuz 5764

Jews wearing earrings
Rabbi Jonathan Blass | 8 Elul 5763

Carrying a baby on Shabbat with no Eruv
Rabbi David Sperling | Sivan 14, 5779

No-wedding days
Rabbi David Sperling | Sivan 20, 5772

Riding in a Car on Shabbat Driven by Non-Jew
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Iyyar 25, 5768

About Olam
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Iyyar 21, 5782

same names
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 23, 5782
