- Torah Portion and Tanach
- Shmot
The Torah study is dedicated
Dedicated to IDF success
Once a King, Always a King?
Our haftara ends (Melachim I, 2:11) with a summary of David’s kingship. He was king for 40 years: 7 in Chevron and 33 in Yerushalayim. However, parallel p’sukim in Shmuel II (5: 4-5) say that he was king for 7 years and 6 months in Chevron and 33 in Yerushalayim; thus, there is a discrepancy over 6 months. Chazal were quite disturbed by the 6 months’ "disappearance," and we find several attempts at explaining it.
The Yerushalmi (Rosh Hashana 1:1) gives technical answers: 1) The larger numbers "swallow up" the smaller ones; i.e., the 40 years and the 7 in Chevron are round numbers. 2) David ruled for only 32½ in Yerushalayim, and it was rounded up to 33 to show respect to Yerushalayim.
However, three other approaches see the missing time as criticism of David for different reasons. Rav Yehuda (Sanhedrin 107a) says that David had leprosy for 6 months, and the Sanhedrin distanced themselves from him (a leper is equated with a dead man). This was in response to David’s sin involving Batsheva and Uriya. Rav Chuna (Yerushalmi, ibid.) said that while David was in flight from the revolt of his son, Avshalom¸ he lacked the status of a king (the context is that if he had needed to bring a korban, it would have been that of a regular person, not a king). This is an indication that the revolt lasted for 6 months, a matter the p’sukim do not address. Finally, Rav Yudan (Yerushalmi, ibid.) said that the 6 months correspond to the 6 months that Yoav fought on David’s behalf against the Edomites (see Melachim I, 11:16). This was arguably against the prohibition to quarrel with that nation (Devarim 2:5). The message was, says Rav Yudan, that when you do not follow the Torah’s precepts in leading the nation, your kingship is not counted. (We should note that according to the Bavli (Bava Batra 21b) the war against Edom was justified.)
The question is what we can learn from these various opinions and the difference between them. Is it possible for the nation to banish a king who was appointed by a prophet and approved by the nation? According to Rav Chuna, David was not considered king at the time the people were behind Avshalom instead of him. The nation gave, and the nation took. When the nation no longer accepts the legal king, he even loses his halachic status. This is in line with the Rambam and Rashbam’s opinion that the concept of "the laws of the kingdom is the law" depends on the populace’s acceptance of the kingdom. According to the other approaches, that which can deprive a king’s rule of legitimacy are severe sins. Deposing can only be done by a prophet such as in the case of Shaul and Yerovam, not by a popular revolt. According to everyone, a leader who was chosen by the people can be removed by the rules that the nation’s representatives set in law.
The Yerushalmi (Rosh Hashana 1:1) gives technical answers: 1) The larger numbers "swallow up" the smaller ones; i.e., the 40 years and the 7 in Chevron are round numbers. 2) David ruled for only 32½ in Yerushalayim, and it was rounded up to 33 to show respect to Yerushalayim.
However, three other approaches see the missing time as criticism of David for different reasons. Rav Yehuda (Sanhedrin 107a) says that David had leprosy for 6 months, and the Sanhedrin distanced themselves from him (a leper is equated with a dead man). This was in response to David’s sin involving Batsheva and Uriya. Rav Chuna (Yerushalmi, ibid.) said that while David was in flight from the revolt of his son, Avshalom¸ he lacked the status of a king (the context is that if he had needed to bring a korban, it would have been that of a regular person, not a king). This is an indication that the revolt lasted for 6 months, a matter the p’sukim do not address. Finally, Rav Yudan (Yerushalmi, ibid.) said that the 6 months correspond to the 6 months that Yoav fought on David’s behalf against the Edomites (see Melachim I, 11:16). This was arguably against the prohibition to quarrel with that nation (Devarim 2:5). The message was, says Rav Yudan, that when you do not follow the Torah’s precepts in leading the nation, your kingship is not counted. (We should note that according to the Bavli (Bava Batra 21b) the war against Edom was justified.)
The question is what we can learn from these various opinions and the difference between them. Is it possible for the nation to banish a king who was appointed by a prophet and approved by the nation? According to Rav Chuna, David was not considered king at the time the people were behind Avshalom instead of him. The nation gave, and the nation took. When the nation no longer accepts the legal king, he even loses his halachic status. This is in line with the Rambam and Rashbam’s opinion that the concept of "the laws of the kingdom is the law" depends on the populace’s acceptance of the kingdom. According to the other approaches, that which can deprive a king’s rule of legitimacy are severe sins. Deposing can only be done by a prophet such as in the case of Shaul and Yerovam, not by a popular revolt. According to everyone, a leader who was chosen by the people can be removed by the rules that the nation’s representatives set in law.
The Jewish Mother
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Tevet 20 5783

One People, One Voice
Rabbi Stewart Weiss | Tevet 23 5781

Reluctant Heroes & Jewish History
Rabbi Stewart Weiss | Tevet 19 5782
Are The Jews Traitors?
Rabbi Yaakov Asher Sinclair | Tevet 19 5782

Rabbi Yossef Carmel
Head of "Eretz Hemda" Dayanut Kollel

Did Paroh and the Egyptians Do Teshuva?
Shvat 1 5782

Too Close for Kedusha?
Adar 7 5777

Waiting For What is Half Yours
Parashat Devarim
8 Av 5765

In the Tzelem of Hashem Did He Make Man
5775

Why Do Children Start With Vayikra?
Rabbi Shaul Yisraeli zt"l | 5771
The Laws of Torah Study
Part 2
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | 5761
A Tale of Two Mothers
Rabbi Yoel Gold | Cheshvan 26 5782
The Laws of Torah Study
part 1
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | 5761

Stock in a non-kosher food compony, or sells chametz on Pesach?
Rabbi Stewart Weiss | Adar 5783

What’s new, Israel?!
Rabbi Stewart Weiss | Adar 5783

Israel's Special Need For Unity
Rabbi Dov Lior | Adar 24 5782
