- Family and Society
- Army and War
Can I Refuse a Bad IDF Military Order?
Following the Expulsion from Gush Katif, there has been talk of late of a possible need to reconquer this area, from which terrorists continually fire rockets at Israel. Must I, as a soldier, agree to this?
Rabbi Dov Lior
Adar II 22 5782
Translated by Hillel Fendel
[Ed. note] This question was asked some 16 years ago, but the message of its response is unfortunately still relevant.
Question: Following the Expulsion from Gush Katif, there has been talk of late of a possible need to reconquer this area, from which terrorists continually fire rockets at Israel. Must I, as a soldier, agree to this? Just because the Prime Minister made a ridiculous decision to leave, saying that we will return if we have to, does this justify forcing us simple soldiers to be the ones to carry out this dangerous and nonsensical policy? Is the value of "unity" within Israel important enough that I have to endanger my life for it? And why need we enter Gaza altogether; why can't we just bomb them from the air, and not have to endanger ourselves?
Answer: These are very weighty questions. You are right that the withdrawal from Gaza was essentially a gift to the terrorists, enabling them to fire at us easily. You are also right that in times of war, there is no such thing as "innocent bystanders" among the enemy. Jewish Law states that if terrorists are in a building, the structure must be bombed, without consideration of who else in the building might be killed.
On the other hand, if our government decides to execute a mission in order to reduce terrorism, this is a very important thing, and one must not refuse an order to take part in it. It is inconceivable that every soldier will decide for himself what missions he is willing to participate in and which ones not. The only orders we can and must refuse are those that negate a Torah commandment. Otherwise, we must carry out all orders.
In order to get articles like this delivered straight to your inbox every week, subscribe to the Israel National Torah newsletter here.
[Ed. note] This question was asked some 16 years ago, but the message of its response is unfortunately still relevant.
Question: Following the Expulsion from Gush Katif, there has been talk of late of a possible need to reconquer this area, from which terrorists continually fire rockets at Israel. Must I, as a soldier, agree to this? Just because the Prime Minister made a ridiculous decision to leave, saying that we will return if we have to, does this justify forcing us simple soldiers to be the ones to carry out this dangerous and nonsensical policy? Is the value of "unity" within Israel important enough that I have to endanger my life for it? And why need we enter Gaza altogether; why can't we just bomb them from the air, and not have to endanger ourselves?
Answer: These are very weighty questions. You are right that the withdrawal from Gaza was essentially a gift to the terrorists, enabling them to fire at us easily. You are also right that in times of war, there is no such thing as "innocent bystanders" among the enemy. Jewish Law states that if terrorists are in a building, the structure must be bombed, without consideration of who else in the building might be killed.
On the other hand, if our government decides to execute a mission in order to reduce terrorism, this is a very important thing, and one must not refuse an order to take part in it. It is inconceivable that every soldier will decide for himself what missions he is willing to participate in and which ones not. The only orders we can and must refuse are those that negate a Torah commandment. Otherwise, we must carry out all orders.
In order to get articles like this delivered straight to your inbox every week, subscribe to the Israel National Torah newsletter here.
Sharp Memory
At the Shabbat Table
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Av 26 5780
Service in the Israeli Army and Lineage – part III
Rabbi Yossef Carmel | Tevet 16 5780
Service in the Israeli Army and Lineage – part II
Rabbi Yossef Carmel | Tevet 10 5780
A Little Order in the Turmoil
Rabbi Haggai Lundin | Sivan 2 5781
Rabbi Dov Lior
Rabbi of the settlement and presiding judge at Kiryat Arba. Rosh Yeshiva of the "Nir" Hesder Yeshiva.
The Laws of G-d Are Truth!
Shvat 26 5783
Honoring the Priesthood in Our Time
Adar I 9 5781
The times of Joshua
Recall the surrounded cities from the days of Joshua!
Adar 7668
Loving Good, Fighting Evil
Tevet 5676
Sukkah Walls
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Tishrei 8 5777
The Days Between Yom Kippur and Sukkot
Rabbi Zalman Baruch Melamed | 5765
The Days Between Yom Kippur and Sukkot
Rabbi Zalman Baruch Melamed | 5765
White and Nice Clothes and Gold on Yom Kippur
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Tishrei 4 5780
Ask The Rabbi: What Should I Do To Prepare For The Fast?
Rabbi Stewart Weiss | 5 Tishrei 5784
The Yom Kippur Avoda
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | 5 Tishrei 5784
פרק א משנה ה-ו
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | 5 Tishrei 5784
