Beit Midrash

  • Sections
  • Peninei Halakha
To dedicate this lesson
Chapter 10: The Laws of Tisha Be-Av

19. The Laws of the Tenth of Av

The Babylonians conquered the Temple on the seventh of Av and set it ablaze toward evening on the ninth of the month, and it continued burning throughout the tenth. The Jewish people refrained from eating meat and drinking wine on that date.

undefined

Rabbi Eliezer Melamed

Cheshvan 27 5782

The Babylonians conquered the Temple on the seventh of Av and set it ablaze toward evening on the ninth of the month, and it continued burning throughout the tenth. R. Yoĥanan commented that had he been alive at the time, he would have established the fast on the tenth of Av, because most of the Temple burned on that day. Some Amora’im adopted a stringency to fast on both the ninth and the tenth of Av. However, the prophets and the Sages established the fast on the ninth of Av, because the beginning of any calamity is more severe than its continuation, and the calamity of the Temple’s destruction began on the ninth of Av (Ta’anit 29a, y. Ta’anit 4:6). Nonetheless, since the majority of the Temple actually burned on the tenth of Av, the Jewish people refrained from eating meat and drinking wine on that date: the whole day according to Sephardic custom, and until midday according to Ashkenazic custom (sa and Rema 558:1).


Most Aĥaronim maintain that, in addition to abstaining from meat and wine, one may not do laundry or wear freshly laundered clothes, get a haircut, listen to happy music, or bathe in hot water on the tenth of Av. However, one may wash with lukewarm water. Some rule leniently, maintaining that one must only abstain from meat and wine, but may bathe, get a haircut, and do laundry without restriction. Ideally, one should follow the more stringent opinion, but one may be lenient under pressing circumstances.24


Another prevalent custom is to refrain from reciting She-heĥeyanu on the tenth of Av, like during the Three Weeks (Ĥida, Kaf Ha-ĥayim 558:8; see above 8:7-8).


When the tenth of Av falls on a Friday, one may get a haircut, do laundry, and bathe in preparation for Shabbat, starting from the morning. If one is pressed for time, he may even start preparing for Shabbat immediately after Tisha Be-Av ends (mb 558:3; ahs 558:2; in the next section, we will explain the laws of the night after the fast when Tisha Be-Av is postponed).


It is customary to postpone Birkat Ha-levana until after Tisha Be-Av, because the berakha must be recited joyously, and we curtail our joy during the Nine Days. Many people recite it immediately after Ma’ariv at the conclusion of the fast, but ideally it is improper to do so. After all, it is difficult to be happy then, when one has yet to drink, eat, wash his face and hands, or put on regular shoes. Therefore, each community should set a time – about an hour or two after the fast – for reciting Birkat Ha-levana, and in the meantime everyone will have a chance to eat and wash themselves somewhat. This way, they will be able to recite the berakha joyously. Where there is concern that postponing Birkat Ha-levana may cause some people to forget to recite it, the congregation may recite it immediately after the fast, but it is best to take a drink and wash one’s face beforehand.25






  1. Those who rule stringently include Maharshal, Baĥ, ma, Eliya Rabba, and others. Many people believe that Ashkenazim are stringent in this regard while Sephardim are lenient, but this is not borne out in the Aĥaronim. Many Sephardic poskim prohibit washing clothes, bathing, and cutting one’s hair on the tenth of Av, including: Ĥida (Maĥzik Berakha 558:1); R. Ĥayim Palachi (Mo’ed Le-khol Ĥai 10:92); and Kaf Ha-ĥayim 558:6. Knesset Ha-gedola (Hagahot Tur §558), Ma’amar Mordechai, and Yeĥaveh Da’at 5:41 rule leniently. bhl states that one may rely on the lenient opinion under pressing circumstances, a view that is shared by most poskim. R. Mordechai Eliyahu rules stringently (Hilkhot Ĥagim 29:3-4), adding that one who is stringent regarding all of the prohibitions for the entirety of the tenth of Av should be commended. Kaf Ha-ĥayim 558:10 concurs.


    In general, the status of the tenth of Av is like that of the Nine Days according to Ashkenazic custom, albeit slightly more lenient. During the Nine Days, it is customary to limit the number of people one invites to a se’udat mitzva in which meat and wine are served. On the tenth of Av, however, we make no such limitations (mb 558:2). Some Ĥasidim have a custom to make a siyum on the night after Tisha Be-Av, because joy is hidden in the day’s inner essence, since the redemption begins then. The poskim also allow one to eat food that was cooked with meat – thus lending it the taste of meat – after the fast (bhl 558:2). It is proper to refrain from sexual relations on the night of the tenth of Av. However, if the wife went to the mikveh that night, or if either the husband or wife is going on a long trip the next day, they should not abstain from sexual relations (mb 558:2, Kaf Ha-ĥayim 558:7).↩︎


  2. We already mentioned this halakha above, 1:16. According to Maharil, Birkat Ha-levana should be postponed to another day. Rema 426:2 states that if Tisha Be-Av falls out on a Thursday, Birkat Ha-levana should be postponed to Motza’ei Shabbat, but if the fast falls out on any other day, the berakha should be recited the next night. However, most Aĥaronim write that one should not delay the mitzva. Rather, one must recite Birkat Ha-levana immediately after Tisha Be-Av. Knesset Ha-gedola, Pri Ĥadash, Ĥida, Ĥayei Adam, and mb 426:11 all concur. Some add another reason: We are somewhat happy on the night after Tisha Be-Av, because according to our tradition, the Messiah is born on Tisha Be-Av; therefore, it is fitting to recite Birkat Ha-levana then. Nonetheless, mb and other Aĥaronim write that it is proper to eat and put on regular shoes before reciting the berakha. See above, 1:16.↩︎




את המידע הדפסתי באמצעות אתר yeshiva.org.il