- Sections
- Bemare Habazak - Rabbis Questions
- Shabbat and Holidays
- The Melachot
Answer: In addition to making sure the kugel and cholent are fully cooked before the transfer, two issues need to be addressed.

Bemare Habazak - Rabbis Questions (586)
Rabbi Daniel Mann
322 - Moving Kugel into a Cholent Pot
323 - Sefarim under Seats
324 - Davening in Front of a Mirror
Load More
However, the matter depends on an important machloket: Is it permitted to move food from a refrigerator on Shabbat morning to a hot plate? Let us briefly explain the opinions and the connection. There are two Rabbinic concerns about returning food to a heat source: one may "stoke the coals" (i.e., raise the setting); placing the food looks like cooking. "Shabbat hot plates" have only one setting, eliminating the concern of adjusting. Regarding looking like cooking, some (Halachos of Shabbos (Eider), p. 313; Am Mordechai, Shabbat 7) argue that since hot plates are made only for reheating, no one will make a mistake. Rav Ovadia Yosef adds that the fact that a hot plate is known to be used only for reheating on Shabbat improves the situation, as does the fact that there is space between the heating element and the metal upon which the pot sits (Yechaveh Da’at II:45). They, thus, posit that the hot plate is not halachically considered "on the fire." The Orchot Shabbat (2:(117)) argues cogently that if someplace is considered "on the fire" enough to forbid taking food from the refrigerator onto it, then one may move food from there to anywhere "on the fire." However, if a place is categorized as "off the fire," such that one may put food from the refrigerator onto it, then it is forbidden to move from that place to a full heat source. It is difficult to argue with this thesis, for if it is wrong, one could take food from the refrigerator to even a stove top with a blech in two steps. First, put it on a weak heat source, and from there move it to a full heat source.
Thus, if you follow the lenient opinions above, regarding the hot plate, you could not move the kugel from there to a crock pot, for the latter is a full heat source, as it is used for cooking food from scratch. If you follow the stringent opinions regarding placing food on a hot plate on Shabbat (such as Shemirat Shabbat K’hilchata 1:25), the laws of chazara would not preclude your moving a kugel from a hot plate to a crock pot. (If one is stringent for a hot plate only out of doubt/chumra, then it would be a problem to treat as a real heat source in order to allow moving from there to a crock pot.)
Another issue is hatmana – insulating something to keep it hot, which is forbidden on Shabbat and sometimes even before Shabbat (see details in Shulchan Aruch, OC 257-8). If the kugel is wrapped in aluminum foil or the like and put in the cholent, with the latter keeping it warm, it seems a candidate for this prohibition. (Food directly within other food is not a problem (Shemirat Shabbat K’hilchata 1:72).) However, there are at least two ways to solve all problems. First, if the kugel is not fully submerged, it is not hatmana (see Mishna Berura 258:2). Second, if one makes holes in the aluminum foil, so that taste of cholent is expected to enter the kugel, the cholent and kugel are considered united enough for hatmana not to apply (Orchot Shabbat 1:93). (Additional grounds for leniency regarding hatmana are beyond our present scope.)

Ask the Rabbi: Changing Diapers in the Proximity of Sefarim
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Kislev 5785

White and Nice Clothes and Gold on Yom Kippur
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Tishrei 4 5780

Ask the Rabbi: Switching Mantels Back on Shabbat
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Kislev 5785

Ask the Rabbi: Should Kiddush Levana Be Done with a Minyan?
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Cheshvan 5785

Rabbi Daniel Mann

Ribbit in a Loan from an Irrevocable Trust Fund
Adar 7 5777

Reciting Borei Nefashot on Food When One Will Still Drink
Sivan 3 5780

Pay for Overtime on Shabbat
5773

Obtaining Arba’ah Minim for the Sukkot after Shemitta
Tisheri 7 5776

Parashat Hashavua: The Ten Commandments – A Blueprint for World Justice
Rabbi Yossef Carmel | Shevat 5785

Ties to Religiously Controversial Events/Organizations 1. #293
Date and Place: Iyar 5670 (1910), Yafo
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Shevat 5785

Defense vs. Lashon HaRah
The Speaker, the Spoken & the Receiver via Rav Kook's New Account of Mephiboshet
Rabbi Ari Shvat | 12 Shevat 5784
