- Torah Portion and Tanach
- Shoftim
The Torah study is dedicated in the memory of
Asher Ben Haim
Parashat Shoftim
The State of Mind of a Head of State
While studying the laws of the Jewish king, found in our parasha, one may ask whether the laws are personal laws for one who occupies that challenging role or whether they are guidelines for running a nation, which are directed at its leader. Let us first review the basic laws of the king.
The king may not acquire too many horses (Devarim 17:16) nor marry many wives nor accumulate much gold and silver (ibid.: 17). The Torah commands him to write a sefer Torah and take it with him so that he will fear Hashem (ibid.:18-19). The instructions are intended to keep him from being haughty or straying from the mitzvot of the Torah (ibid.:20).
The last few p’sukim deal with safeguards for the personal state of the king. But are the matters of accumulating horses, wives, and riches personal or public ones? The Rambam (Melachim 3:3-6) stresses the personal, psychological realm. He says that even one horse that is used just for his honor (and thus does not directly impact on the nation) is forbidden. Similarly he talks about wealth’s likelihood to cause haughtiness and compares it to drinking excessive wine, a weak point of kings. In regard to wives, he says that even if he had one wife with whom he cohabited incessantly "like the rest of the fools," it would be forbidden.
Other Rishonim present the matter differently. Rashi says that he should not have more horses than he needs for his chariots, so that he not cause Jews to go down to Egypt in search of horses. Ibn Ezra says that he should not collect too much gold and silver from the people as a form of punishment. In other words, there should be limitations on high taxation. The Ramban suggests that limiting horses discourages the king from over-reliance on his armed forces. All of these explanations share the element of addressing a specific national concern. Translating these concerns into modern terms, these binding tips relate to the dealings of the three most important ministries in Israel and other states.
The lesson of laws of horses is addressed to the defense apparatus. Do not rely too heavily on a powerful standing army. It places an economic drain on the country. It can also compromise the soldiers’ ability to function normally within society and family, while they are preoccupied with army service for unlimited periods of time.
The matter of wives is actually a warning to the diplomatic corps. Historically, royal marriages with foreign princesses were a major means of advancing international treaties. While diplomacy is good, its indiscriminate use can ruin the fabric of society.
The Torah also has a word for the Ministry of Finance. While the government should try to facilitate healthy, personal wealth, these laws teach us that a life of indulging in luxuries is morally dangerous, both for the king and the citizen.
In brief, our parasha can be instructive in trying to properly operate our Jewish State.
The king may not acquire too many horses (Devarim 17:16) nor marry many wives nor accumulate much gold and silver (ibid.: 17). The Torah commands him to write a sefer Torah and take it with him so that he will fear Hashem (ibid.:18-19). The instructions are intended to keep him from being haughty or straying from the mitzvot of the Torah (ibid.:20).
The last few p’sukim deal with safeguards for the personal state of the king. But are the matters of accumulating horses, wives, and riches personal or public ones? The Rambam (Melachim 3:3-6) stresses the personal, psychological realm. He says that even one horse that is used just for his honor (and thus does not directly impact on the nation) is forbidden. Similarly he talks about wealth’s likelihood to cause haughtiness and compares it to drinking excessive wine, a weak point of kings. In regard to wives, he says that even if he had one wife with whom he cohabited incessantly "like the rest of the fools," it would be forbidden.
Other Rishonim present the matter differently. Rashi says that he should not have more horses than he needs for his chariots, so that he not cause Jews to go down to Egypt in search of horses. Ibn Ezra says that he should not collect too much gold and silver from the people as a form of punishment. In other words, there should be limitations on high taxation. The Ramban suggests that limiting horses discourages the king from over-reliance on his armed forces. All of these explanations share the element of addressing a specific national concern. Translating these concerns into modern terms, these binding tips relate to the dealings of the three most important ministries in Israel and other states.
The lesson of laws of horses is addressed to the defense apparatus. Do not rely too heavily on a powerful standing army. It places an economic drain on the country. It can also compromise the soldiers’ ability to function normally within society and family, while they are preoccupied with army service for unlimited periods of time.
The matter of wives is actually a warning to the diplomatic corps. Historically, royal marriages with foreign princesses were a major means of advancing international treaties. While diplomacy is good, its indiscriminate use can ruin the fabric of society.
The Torah also has a word for the Ministry of Finance. While the government should try to facilitate healthy, personal wealth, these laws teach us that a life of indulging in luxuries is morally dangerous, both for the king and the citizen.
In brief, our parasha can be instructive in trying to properly operate our Jewish State.
Shoftim – Justice
Rabbi Berel Wein | 5769
Sick and Tired
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | 5778

The Place of the Sanhedrin
Parashat Shoftim
Rabbi Mordechai Spiegelman | 5763

Eglah Arufah
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Kislev 18 5780

Rabbi Yossef Carmel
Head of "Eretz Hemda" Dayanut Kollel

Societal Improvement, Clouds, and Canopies
Tishrei 7 5776

Presents, Prayer, and Battle – Always?
5773

The Two Countings of the Nation, Yom Haatzmaut and Yom Yerushalayim
Iyar 26 5777

“On this Day He will Atone You”
Tishrei 4 5776

Writing on Shabbat
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff

The Importance of Work & Secular Knowledge in Elevating the World
Ein Aya Shabbat 4, 5
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Sivan 21 5782

Some Laws Relating to Tu Bishvat
Rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu Zt"l | 7 Shvat 5768

Shabbos Shirah
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Shvat 11 5776

The Day of Love for the Land of Israel
Rabbi Yaakov Ariel | Shvat 12 5783

Guide- Not Deride
Ein Aya Shabbat 5, 15
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Shvat 5783

influencing Our Families, Cities & the World
Ein Aya Shabbat 5,14
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Shvat 5783
