- Sections
- Bemare Habazak - Rabbis Questions
- Shabbat and Holidays
- The Laws of Purim
338
Answer: The gemara (Berachot 27a) says that one may accept the opinion that Ma’ariv can be prayed after plag hamincha. Rabbeinu Tam (Berachot 2a) says that the same is true of Kri’at Shema of the evening. Based on these opinions, the Terumat Hadeshen (109), accepted by the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 692:4), says that in a case of need, one may read Megillat Esther from plag hamincha. Since you describe a case of significant need, this seemingly gives you permission to make the reading from plag hamincha.
However, not everyone accepts the Terumat Hadeshen/Shulchan Aruch. The Pri Chadash (ad loc.) strongly disagrees. He argues that we do not accept Rabbeinu Tam’s opinion about reading Kri’at Shema fromplag haminchan (see Shulchan Aruch, OC 235:1). Also, the gemara(Megilla 4a) derives the night reading from, "I will call out to You in the day … and at night" (Tehillim 22:3). The Pri Chadash says that since night is needed, plag hamincha, which is only close to night, is insufficient, and the time begins with tzeit hakochavim. The Gra (to Shulchan Aruch ibid.) cites the Pri Chadash, and the Chayei Adam (155:5) and the Aruch Hashulcan (692:8) rule like him.
The Mishna Berura (692:14 and Be’ur Halacha) does not clearly decide between the opinions but says that in a case of great need (not the moderate need the Shulchan Aruch refers to), one can read before nightfall. Rav Ovadia Yosef (Yabia Omer I, OC 42) ruled to rely on the lenient opinion, under the following fascinating circumstances – the British placed a strict dusk-to-dawn curfew in Yerushalayim on Purim of 1947, making reading Megilla from plag hamincha the most feasible option. One of the factors he weighed was that according to prominent (although far from unanimous) opinions, the main reading, as mandated by the Megilla itself, is in the daytime, with the night reading being only Rabbinic and thus more lenient.
From a purist halachic perspective, it is hard to quantify what number of extra people coming for early Megilla reading (with morepirsumei nisa) over at the classic time justifies the change. However, your community has a strong kiruv element, which is an overriding consideration, certainly when the lenient position you want to rely upon is accepted by no less than the Shulchan Aruch. You should consider such things as the extent to which, if at all, this leniency affects the community in other ways (e.g., will it dampen the resolve to continue keeping mitzvot carefully if practices that were not previously practiced locally are now accepted?).

Bemare Habazak - Rabbis Questions (598)
Rabbi Daniel Mann
215 - Halachic Status of Bitcoin
216 - Early Reading of Megillat Esther
217 - Returning a Loan Complicated by Currency Changes
Load More
From a purist perspective, there is ample halachic basis to do an early reading without a beracha, as the fulfillment of the mitzva at that time is uncertain. However, the correct desire to have the reading carry its full spirit and impact presumably includes the berachot (see Rav Ovadia’s formulation, ibid.), and the lenient opinions include making them. It is appropriate for you to reread the Megilla at the normal time, without a berachot. Subjective communal/educational factors, which you know better than we, should determine if and whom you should invite to join you.
May you continue to bring "ora v’simcha sason viy’kar" to your community.

Ask the Rabbi: Anonymous Return of Stolen Money
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Nisan 5785

Ask the Rabbi: Halachic Status of Hydroponic Maror
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Shevat 5785

Ask the Rabbi: “Cooked” and Sweetened Wine for Kiddush
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Tevet 5785

Ask the Rabbi: Amen on a Non-Beracha
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Shevat 5785

Rabbi Daniel Mann

Yitro Question
5772

Bikur Cholim by Electronic Means
Shvat 1 5782

Reciting Kri’at Shema at the Very End of its Time
Sivan 21 5779

Encouraging a Child to Criticize His Parent
5774

Abraham’s 10 tests and consequences
Rabbi Avraham (Abe) Abrahami
The Four Fasts of the Destruction
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | Tamuz 5761

Kohanim and the Illusion of Death
Rabbi Chanan Morrison | 5770

Kohanim and the Illusion of Death
Rabbi Chanan Morrison | 5770
Daf Yomi Shevuot Daf 12
R' Eli Stefansky | 15 Iyar 5785

P'ninat Mishpat: A Used Car with a Tendency for Engine Problems
based on ruling 84034 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Iyar 5784
Daf Yomi Shevuot Daf 13
R' Eli Stefansky | 16 Iyar 5785
