- Sections
- P'ninat Mishpat
112
Case: Reuven and Shimon jointly owned a house with an upper level and a lower level. They divided their rights in such a way that they switched use of levels every two years. A fire has made the upper level unusable. Who has to pay for the losses caused by the fire?
Ruling: The gemara discusses in several places the situation of a partnership that turns into "time-sharing." One (Bava Batra 13a) is about brothers who inherited a servant or a non-kosher animal (they both cannot be divided physically). If one brother is the firstborn, he gets to use the inherited matter two days per every day of the other brother. The Ri Migash learns from this that whenever it is not possible or not desired to divide the property or to offer that one should buy it and reimburse the other one, the division is based on time-sharing.

P'ninat Mishpat (771)
Various Rabbis
365 - The Price of a Practical Joke
366 - How Do Time-Share Partners Deal with Damage to Property?
367 - Paying for Non-Kosher Wine
Load More
The gemara (Gittin 42a) says that if a person with the status of half servant/half free man was damaged, if it occurred on a day when he works for himself, he receives the money, and if on a day in which he works for his master, the master receives it. In contrast, if he was killed, so that there is total loss, the special payment is split between his inheritors and his master, regardless of what day this occurred.
Let us apply these principles to our case. Regarding the state of the ownership and refurbishing of the house, which is a matter that is classified as "total loss," we look at Reuven and Shimon as partners and say that they have to join together to pay for damages. Regarding the temporary division of time to use the house, everyone loses according to the time that was theirs. In other words, they keep to their schedule of time-sharing, even if one will lose more time than the other. This is simple, even though it contradicts the S’ma, who raises theories as to assumptions between parties who exchange objects for time.

A Student Who Broke a Camera
Various Rabbis | Tevet 5768

How to Take Payment from a Guarantor – part II
(based on ruling 83023 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts)
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | 9 Adar I 5784

P'ninat Mishpat: Rental of an Apartment that Was Not Quite Ready – part I
based on ruling 82031 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Nisan 5784

Falling Asleep Behind the Steering Wheel
Various Rabbis | 5774

The Solution to 'Risky' Intellectual Topics
Ayn Aya, Shabbat v, 72
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Nisan 5785
Daf Yomi Makkot Daf 15
R' Eli Stefansky | 25 Nisan 5785

Ask the Rabbi: Anonymous Return of Stolen Money
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Nisan 5785
