- Torah Portion and Tanach
- Shmini
Hirsch At Your Table
Sanctifying God’s Name
A brief Dvar Torah on the Parsha, based on R. Samson Raphael Hirsch’s Torah Commentary
ויאמר משה אל אהרן הוא אשר דבר ד’ לאמר בקרובי אקדש ועל פני כל העם אכבד וידום אהרן: (Lv 10:3)
After Aharon’s sons Nadav and Avihu perform the illegal קטורת ceremony, a fire descends from God and consumes them, killing them instantly. Moshe speaks to Aharon about God’s reason for the harsh punishment. Aharon listens, silently accepting the decision.
To understand the rationale for God’s punishment, it is necessary to analyze the phrase בקרובי אקדש (I will be sanctified by those close to Me) and to understand the dual concepts of קידוש השם (sanctifying God’s name) and חילול השם (desecrating God’s name).
The term קידוש השם means that a person is willing to exert all his resources and sacrifice everything in order to fulfill God’s will. An individual who acts in accordance with God’s Torah demonstrates His dominance of the world. Conversely, when a person acts against the Torah, he is guilty of חילול ד' profaning the sanctity of God and undermining His role in the universe. The ultimate expression of קידוש השם is the readiness to sacrifice one’s life rather than commit a gross violation of God’s Torah.
Although every Jew is expected to work to enhance God’s role in society, those closest to God have a special obligation to do so. This is because their acts serve as examples for the general public to emulate. If the Kohanim, who are closest to God, demonstrate their total dedication to Divine service, they bring honor to God (מכובד) in the eyes of the entire nation (עם).
If an ordinary person had committed this sin, it perhaps would have been a pardonable offense. However, for public figures, such as the sons of Aharon, it was a חילול ד'. In order for God’s position of כבוד to be maintained among the people (על פני כל העם), a severe punishment was required. Aharon understood the appropriateness of the punishment and remained silent (וידום) in the face of Moshe’s explanation.
This approach of holding public figures to higher standards stands in stark contrast to the mores of the non-Jewish world, where public figures are usually allowed greater latitude for lapses in morality.
This verse also provides a response to those who negate the existence of the Oral Law (תורה שבעל פה). In the middle of the verse the following phrase appears: הוא אשר דיבר ד' (this is what God said). Nowhere does the Torah mention that God made such a statement. The only possible explanation is that the concept of בקרבי אקדש must have been told to Moshe as part of the Torah that was not written down, that which was transmitted orally. The unfortunate death of the sons of Aharon prompted the mention of the concept in the written Torah. Otherwise, it would have remained exclusively in the Oral Law.
Copyright © 2014, Matityahu Clark. All Rights Reserved. This is an excerpt from the forthcoming Hirsch At Your Table, a collection of brief divrei torah based on R. Samson Raphael Hirsch’s Torah Commentary.
After Aharon’s sons Nadav and Avihu perform the illegal קטורת ceremony, a fire descends from God and consumes them, killing them instantly. Moshe speaks to Aharon about God’s reason for the harsh punishment. Aharon listens, silently accepting the decision.
To understand the rationale for God’s punishment, it is necessary to analyze the phrase בקרובי אקדש (I will be sanctified by those close to Me) and to understand the dual concepts of קידוש השם (sanctifying God’s name) and חילול השם (desecrating God’s name).
The word קרבי is from the root ק-ר-ב "to come close." The role of the Kohen brings him close to God. The words אקדש, קידוש are from the root ק-ד-ש "to dedicate all resources" to a particular goal. God is elevated by the acts of service of those close to Him. The word חילול is from the root ח-ל-ל"to act against".
The term קידוש השם means that a person is willing to exert all his resources and sacrifice everything in order to fulfill God’s will. An individual who acts in accordance with God’s Torah demonstrates His dominance of the world. Conversely, when a person acts against the Torah, he is guilty of חילול ד' profaning the sanctity of God and undermining His role in the universe. The ultimate expression of קידוש השם is the readiness to sacrifice one’s life rather than commit a gross violation of God’s Torah.
Although every Jew is expected to work to enhance God’s role in society, those closest to God have a special obligation to do so. This is because their acts serve as examples for the general public to emulate. If the Kohanim, who are closest to God, demonstrate their total dedication to Divine service, they bring honor to God (מכובד) in the eyes of the entire nation (עם).
The word מכובד is from the root כ-ב-ד "to weigh." In attitudinal terms it refers to "honor" which reflects the "weight" that is given to a person who has achieved greatness. The word עם is from the root ע-מ-ם "to develop without outside interference" close social relationships.
If an ordinary person had committed this sin, it perhaps would have been a pardonable offense. However, for public figures, such as the sons of Aharon, it was a חילול ד'. In order for God’s position of כבוד to be maintained among the people (על פני כל העם), a severe punishment was required. Aharon understood the appropriateness of the punishment and remained silent (וידום) in the face of Moshe’s explanation.
The word פני is from the root פ-נ-ה "to focus". In our verse it refers to the faces of the people. The word וידום is from the root ד-מ-ם "to quiet".
This approach of holding public figures to higher standards stands in stark contrast to the mores of the non-Jewish world, where public figures are usually allowed greater latitude for lapses in morality.
This verse also provides a response to those who negate the existence of the Oral Law (תורה שבעל פה). In the middle of the verse the following phrase appears: הוא אשר דיבר ד' (this is what God said). Nowhere does the Torah mention that God made such a statement. The only possible explanation is that the concept of בקרבי אקדש must have been told to Moshe as part of the Torah that was not written down, that which was transmitted orally. The unfortunate death of the sons of Aharon prompted the mention of the concept in the written Torah. Otherwise, it would have remained exclusively in the Oral Law.
Copyright © 2014, Matityahu Clark. All Rights Reserved. This is an excerpt from the forthcoming Hirsch At Your Table, a collection of brief divrei torah based on R. Samson Raphael Hirsch’s Torah Commentary.

Kosher Animals
Hirsch At Your Table
Rabbi Matityahu Clark

Eretz HaChaim
Parashat Shmini
Rabbi Ari Waxman | Adar B, 5763

Being Embarrassed - Should He or Shouldn't He?
Various Rabbis | Adar 2 5768

The “Eighth” Wonder
Rabbi Stewart Weiss | Adar II 20 5782

Rabbi Matityahu Clark
Served in principal/director positions throughout North America. One of the founders of the Educator's Council of America, and former president of the Council for Jewish Education. Former Director of the Board of Jewish Education of Greater Washington.

The Mission to Spy
Hirsch At Your Table

Kedusha
Hirsch At Your Table

Sh'mita and Mt. Sinai
Hirsch At Your Table

Eliminating Idolatry
Hirsch At Your Table

The Power of a Curse
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks | Iyar 16 5780

Birkat Hamazon
Rabbi Daniel Mann | 5774

Birkat Kohanim in a Shiva House
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Iyar 21 5782

Aftermath of a Complex Partnership – part III
based on ruling 76096 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Iyar 21 5782

More on Rav Kook’s Yeshiva Planning
Igrot Hare’aya – Letters of Rav Kook #102
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Iyar 21 5782
