Beit Midrash

  • Sections
  • P'ninat Mishpat
קטגוריה משנית
To dedicate this lesson
undefined
Case:The defendant (=def) rented an apartment from the plaintiff (=pl). Pl is suing def for not paying rent in full. Def counters that since the heat in the apartment was not working for much of the winter, despite pl’s half-hearted efforts to fix it, and since there were other shortcomings in the apartment, they should not have to pay in full.

Ruling:The Shulchan Aruch (Choshen Mishpat 312:7) rules that if a rented house fell, the renter can reduce the rent corresponding to the time it was down. The Rama (ad loc.) says the same is true if it burns down and that if all the houses in the area burn down, it is a "plague of the region" and the rent is reduced. The Rama’s opinion is unclear because he seems to distinguish between one house burning down and many burning down, but it seems that in both cases a reduction in rent is called for. The S’ma (312:34) and the Taz demonstrate that the Rama cited an opposing opinion (that is missing from our texts) that usually rent is not reduced, after which he added that if it happened to many houses, all agree it is reduced. The Netivot Hamishpat (312:13) says that if the renter agreed to pay in advance, the rent is not reduced, and that is why it has to add that if several houses were burnt, there is a reduction. It emerges that in a case that the house became dysfunctional for part of the time, there is a machloket whether he has to pay in full. The machloket revolves around the question whether one who rents real estate is like the property’s owner for that time. If he is, then just like any other landowner, when something happens to the property, the owner loses.
The aforementioned machloket would seem to apply to cases where the apartment continued to function but on a lower level. However, the Rambam (Sechirut 5:1) and Shulchan Aruch (CM 310:1) rule that if one rented an animal and it got sick so that it worked inefficiently, he has to pay in full. The Ra’avad and Rashba (Bava Metzia 78a) disagree. Most poskim accept the Rambam’s opinion that the renter has to pay in full. However, here there are other reasons to accept def’s claim.
The Rambam’s logic to distinguish between an animal that died in the middle of the rental and a sick animal is that when there is no clear change in the animal, just that it is presently less efficient, we attribute the loss to the misfortune of the renter (P’nei Moshe II:32). However, in this case, many of the apartment’s deficiencies were present at the time of the rental. Therefore, it was not def’s misfortune but pl’s lack of responsibility in not providing a fully functional apartment (see Netivot Hamishpat 310:1). The fact that pl was responsible to fix the deficiencies also changes two things. His responsibility means that when the need for fixing arose, it was pl’s misfortune as well. Also, if he did not fix problems in a timely fashion, he breached the contract in a manner that requires compensation.
Beit din ascertained that pl was negligent in his handling of the situation and assessed a sum to reduce from the rental fee.
fast navigation
Lessons
  • Rabbi Zalman Baruch Melamed
    Rabbi Zalman Baruch Melamed
  • Rabbi David Chai Hacohen
    Rabbi David Chai Hacohen
  • Rabbi Avraham Shapira Zt"l
    Rabbi Avraham Shapira Zt"l
  • Rabbi Haggai Lundin
    Rabbi Haggai Lundin
  • Rabbi Uzi Kalchaim zt"l
    Rabbi Uzi Kalchaim zt"l
  • Rabbi Chaim Drukman
    Rabbi Chaim Drukman
  • Rabbi Shimon Klein
    Rabbi Shimon Klein
  • Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu
    Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu
  • Rabbi Shlomo Shushan
    Rabbi Shlomo Shushan
  • Rabbi Sha'ar Yashuv Hacohen
    Rabbi Sha'ar Yashuv Hacohen
    undefined
    Beha'alotcha

    The Consolation of Lighting the Menora - Rav Kook at the Third Shabbat Meal

    15 Sivan 5784
    undefined
    Beha'alotcha

    Why Was Miriam Punished?

    Rabbi Yosef Tzvi Rimon | 5777
    undefined
    Prayer

    ?How we should dress for Prayer

    Chapter five-part two

    Chapter five-part two

    Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | 5775
    undefined
    Prayer

    Who Can Be Counted in a Minyan?

    Chapter Two-part three

    Can every ten men be a Minyan or are there other conditions?

    Rabbi Eliezer Melamed
    undefined
    P'ninat Mishpat

    Historical View of Rav Mordechai Yaakov Breish (Chelkat Yaakov)

    Various Rabbis | 5775
    undefined
    Happy Occasions

    Fasting and Feasting on a Yahrzeit

    “My father’s yahrzeit falls during the week of sheva brachos for my grandson. May I attend the sheva brachos?” "My yahrzeit falls on Shabbos this year. Do I fast on Friday or Sunday instead?" "I usually fast on my father’s yahrzeit, but someone is honoring me with sandaka’us on that day. Do I fast, and do I need to be matir neder in the event that it is permitted to eat?"

    Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff
    undefined
    Revivim

    Halakha on Abortion of Fetuses with Severe Abormalities

    A fetus is considered a living entity in regards to certain laws, but there is no penalty of death for taking its life. What do the rabbinical decisors say?

    Rabbi Eliezer Melamed
    undefined
    Jewish Holidays

    The Twentieth of Sivan

    "I noticed that the back of my siddur contains a large section devoted to selichos for the 20th of Sivan, yet I have never davened in a shul that observed this day. What does this date commemorate?"

    Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Sivan 17 5780
    undefined
    The Giving of the Torah

    The Day of the Rains and the Giving of the Torah

    According to our Sages, The Day of the Rain is as great as, or even greater than the day of the Giving of the Torah. The basis for this comparison is discussed in depth, as well as additional aspects of the connection between the rains and the Torah.

    Rabbi Uzi Kalchaim zt"l | 5770
    undefined
    The Torah Perspective

    Secular Zionism in the Eyes of Rav Kook.

    How can we understand the rebellion against religion over the past century? What does the world gain spiritually from this rebellion which was foreseen in the mishna 1,800 years ago as part of the period preceding the mashiach? Only after we understand the rebellion can we glean the benefit and relate to our brothers properly.

    Rabbi Ari Shvat | 5769
    undefined
    Redemption - Geula

    When Moshiach Comes

    A summary of the different Brachot we will bless when the Moshiach will walk through the door.

    Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Iyar 5768
    undefined
    Marriage and Relationships

    The Role of Parents in Marriage

    Today, parents can fulfill the commandment of marrying off their children by providing them with a good education at prestigious schools, supporting them so that they be able to learn a profession, and clothing them in attractive attire.

    Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | 5764
את המידע הדפסתי באמצעות אתר yeshiva.org.il