- Sections
- P'ninat Mishpat
part II
Wrong Way Collision
Case: The plaintiff (=pl) pulled out of his driveway and banged into the defendant’s (=def) car, as the latter was driving in reverse on a one-way street, causing damage to both cars. Pl claims that since def drove against the traffic rules, def is responsible for the accident. Pl claims to have pulled out slowly and says that he had no reason to suspect a car would be coming from the wrong direction. Def counters that since pl anyway had to look in both directions due to pedestrians, he was at fault for not seeing and avoiding def’s car. [Last week we discussed why def is responsible for damages to pl’s car and not vice versa.]
Def offered to pay pl for his damages using an auto garage that he knows. Pl refused, based on the advice of his insurance agent, and had the damage professionally appraised, after which he took the car to an expensive garage. The cost was 15,000 shekels, including the appraisal. Def says that he could have had it fixed for 4,000 shekels, had pl agreed to his garage.
Ruling: The gemara (Bava Kama 85a) discusses the medical payments of one who caused bodily damage to another. The gemara says that if the damager says that he wants to heal the injured person himself, the latter can refuse. Likewise, he can refuse for the damager to bring someone to heal him for free. As the gemara explains, the (lack of) quality one gets when the healer is not paid is expected to show. Similarly, one cannot bring a doctor who lives in a distant place because he does not have the same level of accountability. However, the underlying concept that we see from the gemara is that if the means of remedying the situation are reasonable, the damager, who has to pay, has a say in choosing the means of remedying the situation.
Thus, to the extent that def is to pay, it is his right to try to negotiate as cheap as reasonable a price for fixing the car, on condition that is within accepted standards. By employing a professional appraiser, one has to add to the cost of the appraiser the fact that once he has set a price, there is no leverage to get a garage to do the work for cheaper. Therefore, since def agreed to pay for damages through his sources, pl should have gone through that process.
At this point, pl has two options. If he wants to receive payment from the insurance company, he is likely to receive the full amount set by the appraiser (which is why he originally used one), and he can proceed in that way. If he continues to sue def directly, then he is entitled only to the sum of a more reasonably priced professional job. Beit din has the authority given to it by those who sign the arbitration agreement to employ their own experience and reason. (This is the correct approach, as a further appraisal will just add to the price). They set the price at 9,060 shekels.
Def offered to pay pl for his damages using an auto garage that he knows. Pl refused, based on the advice of his insurance agent, and had the damage professionally appraised, after which he took the car to an expensive garage. The cost was 15,000 shekels, including the appraisal. Def says that he could have had it fixed for 4,000 shekels, had pl agreed to his garage.
Ruling: The gemara (Bava Kama 85a) discusses the medical payments of one who caused bodily damage to another. The gemara says that if the damager says that he wants to heal the injured person himself, the latter can refuse. Likewise, he can refuse for the damager to bring someone to heal him for free. As the gemara explains, the (lack of) quality one gets when the healer is not paid is expected to show. Similarly, one cannot bring a doctor who lives in a distant place because he does not have the same level of accountability. However, the underlying concept that we see from the gemara is that if the means of remedying the situation are reasonable, the damager, who has to pay, has a say in choosing the means of remedying the situation.
Thus, to the extent that def is to pay, it is his right to try to negotiate as cheap as reasonable a price for fixing the car, on condition that is within accepted standards. By employing a professional appraiser, one has to add to the cost of the appraiser the fact that once he has set a price, there is no leverage to get a garage to do the work for cheaper. Therefore, since def agreed to pay for damages through his sources, pl should have gone through that process.
At this point, pl has two options. If he wants to receive payment from the insurance company, he is likely to receive the full amount set by the appraiser (which is why he originally used one), and he can proceed in that way. If he continues to sue def directly, then he is entitled only to the sum of a more reasonably priced professional job. Beit din has the authority given to it by those who sign the arbitration agreement to employ their own experience and reason. (This is the correct approach, as a further appraisal will just add to the price). They set the price at 9,060 shekels.

P'ninat Mishpat (657)
Various Rabbis
211 - Wrong Way Collision
212 - Wrong Way Collision
213 - Access to a Sold but Illegal Storage Area
Load More

Disappointment with Arba Minim Sales Provisions – part I
based on ruling 74082 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Nissan 10 5782

Aftermath of a Complex Partnership – part II
based on ruling 76096 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Iyar 16 5782

Unfair Competition?
Various Rabbis | 5772

Why Was the Etrog Order Changed? – part
based on ruling 74026 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Tevet 13 5781

Various Rabbis
Various Rabbis including those of of Yeshivat Bet El, such as Rabbi Chaim Katz, Rabbi Binyamin Bamberger and Rabbi Yitzchak Greenblat and others.

Thanking Hashem for a Variety of Valuable People
5773

Returning Tuition When a Student Was Expelled – part II
Shvat 5773

Levels of Thanks
5771

Presence of Hashem in the Mind of a Sinner
5773

How Many Eggs Should be Boiled Together?
Rabbi Daniel Mann

How Many Eggs Should be Boiled Together?
Rabbi Daniel Mann
President Herzog visits Rabbi Wein
Rabbi Berel Wein | Nissan 17 5782

The Halachos of Pidyon Haben
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Sivan 29 5778
Exploitation through compound interest
Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu | Iyar 12 5782
Inventing Religion
Rabbi Yaakov Asher Sinclair | Iyar 10 5782

Missing the Reading
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Iyar 17 5782
