- Sections
- Ein Ayah
Taking the Good While Avoiding the Bad
Gemara:
Ein Ayah: Besides the practical advice in these statements, there is a philosophical idea that is hinted at. Whenever there is something which we can enjoy, we should look both at its benefits and its drawbacks and plan how to gain from the former without being harmed by the latter. This is true not only of foods but of desirable elements in the world in general.
There are matters that make things more pleasant and glorious in the external realm but may sometimes cause internal deterioration. It is a mistake, then, for one to think that he may pursue the external gains without considering the potential damage. He will regret later that he received just "a flower that wilted" so quickly while he lost critical vigor in the eternal world.
For someone to refuse and even despise the external benefit is also not a proper thing because everything that Hashem made in this world is for His honor, and everything that can broaden one’s life and make it more splendid contains the completeness that is appropriate according to its value. Thus, it is proper to make use of the external matters, but in a wise way that will avoid the damage while obtaining the benefit.
Chazal taught us an example of the concept regarding benefits and dangers in the physical realm [spleen and leeks], warning us not to take the good in a manner that will bring either internal or even external harm. Indeed, if one only ponders abstract wisdom in the realm of understanding Hashem, even though it will cause his spirit to grow, if he goes too far and leaves behind his normal life, it can have a negative impact on his human spirit.
When Man Should and Should Not Intervene With Nature
(condensed from Ein Ayah, Berachot 6:67)
Gemara:
Ein Ayah: It is proper to love nature as is, for it is the work of Hashem, and to not always occupy himself with artificial things. While this is true regarding both one’s physical and spiritual lifestyles, one should be aware of the following two things.
One is that if there is something natural that was made in order to join together with something man-made, then one should not suffice with its natural completion. Since man’s intellect is also a part in the natural world, the object’s "point of completion" is actually when man is finished with it. Thus, a raw vegetable may very well not be complete until man completes it through cooking, which is also a natural action.
Another observation is that there are things that do not need human intervention, and there is a need for them to reach their completion. If man takes such an object when it is still small and not ready, it will never reach its completion.
In general, we can say that man sometimes has desires that seem natural, but the problem is that he is not ready to wait until they are at their correct stage, when they will give the full benefit. Taking them before the time will just leave man himself small and incomplete.
[Eating] spleen is good for the teeth and bad for the intestines. What is the solution for it? Chew it and then spit it out. Leeks are hard on the teeth and good for the intestines. What is the solution for it? Cook it well and then swallow it.
Ein Ayah: Besides the practical advice in these statements, there is a philosophical idea that is hinted at. Whenever there is something which we can enjoy, we should look both at its benefits and its drawbacks and plan how to gain from the former without being harmed by the latter. This is true not only of foods but of desirable elements in the world in general.
There are matters that make things more pleasant and glorious in the external realm but may sometimes cause internal deterioration. It is a mistake, then, for one to think that he may pursue the external gains without considering the potential damage. He will regret later that he received just "a flower that wilted" so quickly while he lost critical vigor in the eternal world.
For someone to refuse and even despise the external benefit is also not a proper thing because everything that Hashem made in this world is for His honor, and everything that can broaden one’s life and make it more splendid contains the completeness that is appropriate according to its value. Thus, it is proper to make use of the external matters, but in a wise way that will avoid the damage while obtaining the benefit.
Chazal taught us an example of the concept regarding benefits and dangers in the physical realm [spleen and leeks], warning us not to take the good in a manner that will bring either internal or even external harm. Indeed, if one only ponders abstract wisdom in the realm of understanding Hashem, even though it will cause his spirit to grow, if he goes too far and leaves behind his normal life, it can have a negative impact on his human spirit.
When Man Should and Should Not Intervene With Nature
(condensed from Ein Ayah, Berachot 6:67)
Gemara:
All green vegetables take away one’s good complexion. Everything that is not fully grown makes one small.
Ein Ayah: It is proper to love nature as is, for it is the work of Hashem, and to not always occupy himself with artificial things. While this is true regarding both one’s physical and spiritual lifestyles, one should be aware of the following two things.
One is that if there is something natural that was made in order to join together with something man-made, then one should not suffice with its natural completion. Since man’s intellect is also a part in the natural world, the object’s "point of completion" is actually when man is finished with it. Thus, a raw vegetable may very well not be complete until man completes it through cooking, which is also a natural action.
Another observation is that there are things that do not need human intervention, and there is a need for them to reach their completion. If man takes such an object when it is still small and not ready, it will never reach its completion.
In general, we can say that man sometimes has desires that seem natural, but the problem is that he is not ready to wait until they are at their correct stage, when they will give the full benefit. Taking them before the time will just leave man himself small and incomplete.

Keep it Simple!
based on Ein Ayah, Shabbat 14:13
Beit Din Eretz Hemda - Gazit | Tevet 2 5781

The Benefits of Admonishing Even When Unheeded
Ein Aya Shabbat 5,17
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Adar 5783

Extreme Physicality and Extreme Spirituality
condensed from Ein Ayah, Berachot 9:225
Various Rabbis | 23 Tevet 5773

The Need for the Spirit by the Letter of the Law
Various Rabbis | 5769

Various Rabbis
Various Rabbis including those of of Yeshivat Bet El, such as Rabbi Chaim Katz, Rabbi Binyamin Bamberger and Rabbi Yitzchak Greenblat and others.

Accepting a Person’s Past Background
5774

Responsibility for Collateral
5774

Four Prototypes of Service of Hashem
5774

Connection to the Present and the Past
Iyar 21 5775

The Month of Nissan - A Unique Possession
Rabbi Chaim Avihau Schwartz | nissan 5762

Behind the Mishkan’s Measurements
Parashat Terumah
Rabbi Yossef Carmel | 5764
Soaps and Cosmetics Kosher for Passover? (And a review of Pesach laws)
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed | 5575
As Though You Yourself Came Out of Egypt
Rabbi Gideon Weitzman | 5765
The Secret Love
Rabbi Netanel Yossifun | Nissan 2 5783

Mechirat Chametz and Tevillat Keilim
Rabbi Daniel Mann | Nissan 5783
What Is the Worth of Shiny Gold?
Rabbi Zalman Baruch Melamed | Adar 24 5783
