Sign in | Register
 
 
 
Bookmark and Share RSS for this category Rss Search Options
Hello Guest, ( Login / register )


Kislev 16, 5770

Canned Salmon


Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt

Question:
Is there a problem with canned salmon with sea lice?

Answer:
I discussed this with R Victor the fish supervisor of the Machon Lmitzvot Hatluyot Baaretz of Rabbi S.Z. Revach. He says that the current situation is that Salmon from the USA and China are usually ocean fish that are commonly infested with Anisakis worms that are in the meat of the fish, and since it is very difficult to clean them, one should not eat these fish.

Rabbi Moshe Vaye told me that according to most great Poskim, Anisakis worms that are in the meat of the fish are permitted as stated in Shulchan Aruch Yoreh Deah 84, 16. Because at the time that they were swallowed by the fish they were microscopic creatures that are not forbidden, and what grew inside the fish is permitted, except for the worms in the intestines that are forbidden. Therefore fish that is imported from the USA or China should not be prohibited. However the intestines should be cleaned well, to make sure all worms are removed.

Salmon from Norway and Chile are usually fresh water fish that grow in cages. They are not usually infested with Anisakis worms. But they are commonly infested with Lepeophtheirus Salamonis - Salmon Lice that stick to the skin of the Salmon. They are seen clearly and are easily removed.

Canned Salmon; according to Rabbi Revachs Machon and the Rabbis supporting them, it should not be eaten if it is from the USA or China because of the problem of Anisakis worms. If it is from Norway or Chile there is most probably no problem with Salmon lice because the skin is removed before it is canned. It is recommended to buy it with a good Hechsher to be sure no Lice found its way to the cans. Rabbi Vaye disagrees; he told me that one can buy canned salmon from the USA or China that is under a good Hashgachah, who make sure to clean the intestines well from all the worms.

In any case it is highly recommended to buy fish under a good Hashgachah that is familiar with the worms and sea lice issues or consult Kashrut experts in every specific case, because things change from time to time and place to place.


I want to ask a question related to this answer



Yeshiva.org.il
The Torah World Gateway