- Shabbat and Holidays
- Megilla Reading
Yotze the megillah reading from the radio?
Question
On motzaei shabbat, I heard the megillah being read from kol chai radio station. I wanted to know if that leining could be considered a true leining? Would I have been yotze from that reading?
Why or why not? And if not, why do they lein it from the radio then?
Answer
Shalom,
Thank you for your question. Much has been written about hearing the migillah via the radio, or even via a loudspeaker (see for example Shut Yechavay Da'at 3,54, and the Tzit Eliezer 4,26). The overwhelming ruling of rabbis today is that one should not fulfill their mitzvah of listening to the migillah via the radio, (though they debate the possibility that perhaps after the fact, or in times of great need, whether one can rely on hearing the megillah via the radio).
The main issue at hand is whether what one hears from the radio's speaker is in fact the voice of the person reading. In order to fulfill the mitzvah one needs to hear the reading from someone who is themselves obligated in the mitzvah. So if, for example, one heard the reading from a trained parrot, everyone agrees that the mitzvah was not fulfilled (though that would be some Purim act!). Also, if one heard a recording of the migillah reading, it would not suffice. So, is the electrical reproduction of the broadcast voice from the radio considered as a "voice" of the reader or not? That is the question the rabbis debate when it comes to listening to the migillah via a speaker or radio.
Even though we wrote that the main stream ruling is to be strict, it is still a great thing that the national radio station broadcasts the megillah reading (for not only the private religious station broadcast it, but also the national station – Kol Yisrael). This is for two reasons. Firstly, there are opinions that hold that one can fulfill the mitzvah in this way, and it is certainly better than not hearing the megillah at all. So for those people who will not get to a synagogue reading, this is the next best thing. Secondly, even if no one fulfills their mitzvah by the radio reading, it is still a great Kiddush Hashem (sanctification of G-d's name) to have the national radio station's prime time used to broadcast words from the Tanach – may we merit to increase all types of Torah in Israel!
Blessings.

Megillah
Rabbi David Sperling | Tevet 3, 5775

to listen to the doctor
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Adar II 29, 5779

Hearing the megillah in Israel
Rabbi David Sperling | Adar II 7, 5771

Megillah reading
Various Rabbis | 7 Adar 5766

Rabbi David Sperling

salary on shabbat
Nisan 23, 5771

Tashlumin on Rosh Chodesh
Iyyar 7, 5771

Guests driving on Shabbat
Nisan 25, 5771

Reheating Food in an oven on Shabbat
Adar II 24, 5771

money on Shabbat
Rabbi David Sperling | Tammuz 20, 5775

Mezzuzah for Non Jew
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 18, 5773

Mezzuzah for Non Jew
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 18, 5773

Popcorn at the cinema
Rabbi David Sperling | Nisan 8, 5773

Troubled by Basic Questions: God, Torah, Running the World..
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Iyyar 27, 5783
Automatic watch
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Iyyar 23, 5783
rafael or refael
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Iyyar 27, 5783
