- Family and Society
- General Questions
243
Question
I was hired to drive a truck with lots of stuff upstate. I hired a friend to help me. The people who hired me knew about this friend. At one point he took the truck with empty suitcases in the back. He forgot to close the door in the back. One suitcase fell out and could not be found. Do I pay worker? Who is responsible to pay owner of suitcase for his loss? If I paid worker already do I have the right to ask for money back?
Answer
It is difficult to give an answer without talking to all parties personally, to find out all the details accurately. Therefore the following answer is according to the description in the question, but in practice one should consult a rabbi in person.
You and your friend have the Halachic status of a paid bailee (Shomer Sachar) which is responsible for theft, loss, and needless to say also negligence (Shach, Choshen Mishpat, 303, 1).
The case you describe is a classic case of negligence by the fact that he forgot to close the back door, causing loss of one of the suitcases. This case is considered negligence and therefore he must pay for it (Shach, Choshen Mishpat, 291, 3, and all the more so by a paid bailee).
The person who employed you can demand it from you, because you're the only one who was employed by him and must bear full responsibility. Therefore you are responsible to pay the owner for the suitcase.
You can of course demand it from your employee who must pay for the loss. You can hold back from paying him up to the amount of the value of the briefcase and demand money back if you have already paid him.
It is important to note that the amount to be paid for the suitcase is not the price of a new one, but the price of that particular suitcase. If it's used or worn, the price drops accordingly.

Halacha of currency trading
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | Tammuz 9, 5769

Follow Up To Cobal Mitzvah Dilemma
Rabbi David Sperling | Sivan 1, 5780

paying cash to avoid taxes
Rabbi David Sperling | Cheshvan 9, 5780
On money sent by mistake
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Nisan 22, 5774

Mikvah for unmarried women
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | 16 Tevet 5766
Pottery Painting on chol hamoed?
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Nisan 7, 5782

Walking through a church
Rabbi David Sperling | Elul 14, 5773

Chol Hamoed and laundry
Rabbi Chaim Tabasky | 3 Cheshvan 5766

Tithe
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Shevat 4, 5785

Havara- Sefaradic or Ashkenazic Pronunciation
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Nisan 17, 5785

Which Prophets did Israel kill?
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Adar 25, 5785
