Ask the Rabbi
- Family and Society
- The Nation of Israel
- Attitude Towards Secular and Reform Jews
Question
when does one stop being a tinok shinoshba and become a non-tinok shinoshba?
Answer
Shalom,
Thank you for your question. The concept of a “tinok she’nishba” refers to a person who was raised without the benefit of a Torah environment. Because of that, the way Jewish laws relates to them is with more “mercy” – and does not expect of them that which we might expect of someone who grew up in a Torah environment.
The exact application of this concept, and the measure of “lack of knowledge” is not clear at all. It may well depend on when you want to use it, as the levels of ignorance may differ for different subjects.
So, unfortunately, I cannot give you a straight clear answer. Perhaps if you write about the exact application and situation you are dealing with, we could perhaps give a better answer.
Blessings.

Can a Jew who doesnt keep Shabbat get a aliyah to the Torah?
Rabbi David Sperling | Tishrei 29, 5780

Aliya to uncles on Barmitzvah date
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | 10 Sivan 5766

Referring to a non-Orthodox religious leader as "Rabbi"
Rabbi Jonathan Blass | 1 Sivan 5766



