Ask the Rabbi
- Torah and Jewish Thought
- Torah Study
- General Questions
Question
Recently I heard from Muslims that Ezra 2 and Nehemiah 7 contradict each other and that the Tanakh is corrupt and Judaism is nonsense. I have doubts about my faith because the numbers are different and the numbers don’t add up to what they are supposed to add up to. Is their anyway that this can be resolved.
Answer
The question is famous, as is the answer, for anyone who's really interested.
The difference in number is less than 1,500, and is based upon Ezra 2, 64, which refers to "all the people who came [together] as one". That larger number includes those who were already in Israel when Zrubavel came, so they didn't actually come together with everyone else.

Learning Chumash/Rashi at Night II
Rabbi Jonathan Blass | 11 Cheshvan 5763

Shechina and the degree of it while learning
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Cheshvan 19, 5784





