- Torah and Jewish Thought
- Torah Teachings
Re-eh vs. Mishpatim
Question
Last weeks Parsha uses the word "nivalah," which I understand to mean an otherwise kosher animal that dies on its own, and says that "you shall not eat it, but you may give it to the stranger in your cities . . . or you may sell it to a foreigner."
In contrast, Parsha Mispatim uses the word "treifa," which I understand to mean an otherwise kosher animal that dies by being torn by beasts, and says that "...and flesh torn in the field you shall not eat; you shall throw it to the dogs."
The Ibn Ezra says with respect to treifa is that it is only fit for the dogs, and Rashi says that treifa is the dogs reward for not barking when the Israelites left Egypt. It seems then that treifa must be given to the dogs, and not sold or given to gentiles.
Notwithstanding the modern use of "treif" as anything not kosher:
So why then do the majority of the commentaries seemingly claim that treifa and nivalah mean the same thing? In my humble opinion, this does not appear to be correct; otherwise the Chumash would have used the same word in both instances.
Any thoughts?
Answer
You are correct, that neveila and treifa are different, but the truth is, all commentaries agree as well (as is clear from their roots), just that some of their halachot are similar, while others are different, e.g. that the treifa is best to give to dogs, and neveila can be sold l'chatchila to gentiles.

COMPLAINTS AGAINST OUR GEMARRAH OR TALMUD
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Tishrei 6, 5778

Sefer Hachinuch
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | 27 Cheshvan 5765

Rambam on Shedim (demons)
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | 18 Shevat 5765

Question about Parashat Emor
Rabbi David Sperling | Adar I 9, 5782

Rabbi Ari Shvat
Lectures at various yeshivot, michlalot and midrashot. Has published many books & Torani articles and is in charge of Rav Kook’s archives.

baruch hamavdil
Adar I 23, 5771

Gentile Prophets
Adar II 25, 5771

Yericho conquest by Yehoshua
Tevet 28, 5771

Delaying aliya for career and studies
Adar II 25, 5771

When does the Jewish day begin?
Rabbi David Sperling | Nisan 10, 5775

The Latest Time to do Birkat HaLevana
Various Rabbis | 8 Tevet 5764

Mezzuzah for Non Jew
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 18, 5773

Bracha on water
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | Cheshvan 16, 5769

Shema
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Kislev 13, 5784

Must I Delete Photos About Other Religions?
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Kislev 8, 5784

Children of a Converted Reform Woman
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Kislev 10, 5784
