- All the Questions
Dying to save someone else’s life
Question
Does the mishnah or the Talmud say that a righteous person can die for some one else, if so where in either of these books, does it say that?
Robert Roman
Answer
Shalom. In time of war, we find throughout the Tanach that the Bible heroes were military heroes, and as such, often altruistically risked their lives to save others. Even though they usually came out alive, we know that a natural part of every war is that there are casualties, and some missions even know ahead of time that the warriors will definitely not survive. Nevertheless, one is clearly allowed to give his life to save the nation of Israel or even individual Jews in time of war (Minchat Chinuch, 425). However, it should be stressed that the idea is not to glorify death but to guarantee national life, and even this is only during war. Contrarily, in regular times, one is not allowed to give their life to save another’s (for who says the other’s blood is “redder” than yours?, Bava Metziah, 62a), but only to possibly endanger himself in order to definitely save someone else. For example, one is allowed, yet not obligated, to donate a kidney to others, if it will save your friend and for you, it just may sometime cause danger in the future (Or Same’ach).
We do find in a midrash, as if it were, that Adam volunteered to give David 70 years of his life, explaining why Adam died at the age of 930 rather than 1,000, and David lived until the age of 70 (Yalkut Shimoni, Breishit 41). On the other hand, as you probably are aware, we do not learn halacha from midrashim, which are meant to teach ideas, philosophy, mysticism or the like, rather we learn the laws from the Talmud and halachic sources. How much more so, when parallel editions of that Midrash (Otzar HaMidrashim, p. 479) are significantly different, saying that G-d took those years from Adam, for halachically, Adam would not be allowed to shorten his life for the sake of David’s.
With Love of Israel,
Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

plata cover
Rabbi Yirmiyohu Kaganoff | Tishrei 25, 5769

How can someone change their community?
Rabbi David Sperling | Shevat 11, 5783
Apartment Eviction
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Shevat 9, 5783

Why do the havdala candles have two wicks?
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Kislev 13, 5783

Rabbi Ari Shvat
Lectures at various yeshivot, michlalot and midrashot. Has published many books & Torani articles and is in charge of Rav Kook’s archives.

Orla
Shevat 19, 5771

Keeping non-definite chametz and staying in a dorm
Nisan 3, 5771

Bircat baalat habayit
Shevat 7, 5771

Investing in firm selling Chametz
Adar I 23, 5771

Shaitels for non-married women
Rabbi David Sperling | Tammuz 29, 5779

Mezzuzah for Non Jew
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 18, 5773

When does the Jewish day begin?
Rabbi David Sperling | Nisan 10, 5775

On which day may one start wishing "Shabbat Shalom"?
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 9, 5780
Praying with people placing Tefillin on forehead?
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Shevat 9, 5783

Organization
Various Rabbis | Shevat 10, 5783

How can someone change their community?
Rabbi David Sperling | Shevat 11, 5783
