- Family and Society
- General Questions
Shemitta/ Loans/Prosbul
Question
A lot of controversy regarding the loopholes and solutions for Shemitta has occurred this year - my question is, why isn’t the Law of release of debts on the 7th year applied today, since it is obviously part of the shemitta year. And if it does apply, is the prozbul still valid? And if the prozbul was acceptable, why is the hetermechira scorned upon?
Answer
The laws of release of debts (which takes place at the end of the shmitta year) do apply today, and the pruzbul is still valid. Your question about the difference between pruzbul and "heter mechira may be approached from several angles.
Pruzbul is mentioned in the Talmud and required the enactment of a law (by Hillel and the sanhedrin) to apply, whereas the idea of selling land in Israel to non Jews to avoid shmitta is not mentioned or suggested in the Talmud or in early sources. Furthermore, selling the land in Israel generally is prohibited, while pruzbul requires no prohibited act. (Those who accept the "heter mechira" can show numerous sources that a temporary sale of land in Israel for benifit to settlement of the land is permitted, but it is at least a bone of contention).
However, you have a valid point that there are paralels between these two ideas.

Orlah fruit trees
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Adar I 5, 5771

Gush Katif
Various Rabbis | 10 Shevat 5765

Tu Bishvat and Shmita
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Shevat 3, 5775

Shmita and Charity
Various Rabbis | 9 Cheshvan 5768

Rabbi Chaim Tabasky
Rabbi Chaim Tabasky teaches a shiur in gemarah at the Beit Midrash program of the Machon Hagavoah l'Torah at Bar Ilan University. He is also a certified examiner of STa"M (Sifrei Torah, Tefillin and Mezuzot) and a narrative therapist.

Can a Male Ger Become a Rabbi?
12 Av 5764

Women in the ’Halacha’
12 Sivan 5764

Tzniut in the Torah
29 Iyyar 5764

Can One Say Torah is Boring?
19 Sivan 5764

Bracha on water
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | Cheshvan 16, 5769

Bracha on water
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | Cheshvan 16, 5769
Genesis 24: 2-9 – Put your hand under my thigh
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Tevet 26, 5770

Giving Tzdaka with Right Hand
Rabbi David Sperling | Tammuz 28, 5772

How can someone change their community?
Rabbi David Sperling | Shevat 11, 5783
How to split expenses for a group event
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Shevat 9, 5783
