Ask the Rabbi
- Shabbat and Holidays
- Shabbat
- General Questions
Question
What is wrong with giving flowers to someone on Shabbat? May one put flowers in a vase? What Melacha would this be?
Answer
Conducting transfer of property ("kinyan") is not allowed on Shabbat, with the exception of foodstuffs which could be served at the meal (though they don't have to be served). Flowers are no exception, though thaey may be given before Shabbat.
Placing flowers in a vase with water is not allowed, since it appears to be "watering" which is a subcategory of planting. (It is not actually planting, but similar enough for the Rabbis to tell us not to do it.
Asking another to goy on Shabbat
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Adar I 6, 5784

39 labors forbidden on Shabbat
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Shevat 30, 5782

Ordering online on Friday
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Tevet 12, 5780





