Ask the Rabbi
- Torah and Jewish Thought
- Observing Mitzvot & Repentence
- Women's Mitzva Observance
Question
Why is a women allowed to make a berachoh on mitzvot they are not obligated to do (like lulav and etrog for example) if in the berachah we recite "vetzivanu"- and has commanded us if we were not commanded? It seems as if we are lying if we were not commanded?
Answer
This is a good and ancient question
The Rambam (Tzitzit 3, 9) writes that women should not say the Brachah for Mitzvot they are not oblige to do as they can’t say “Vetzivanu” – and he had commanded us;
Rabenu Tam holds that they can say the Brachah as for the word Vetzivanu – that refers to the men and the Jewish people as a whole.
The Shulchan Aruch (OC 589, 6) holds like the Rambam, which is the standard Sephardic custom; and the Rema (OC 17, 2) like Rabenu Tam, which is the standard Ashkenazi custom.

Hair covering
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 23, 5779

Breaking Bread on Shabbat
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | 25 Iyyar 5766

women’s profession
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Tammuz 22, 5780




