- Shabbat and Holidays
- General Questions
Message of Purim
Question
I understand why we rejoice on Purim-that our lot was changed for the good and we were saved from our enemies. But doesn’t the fact that we were almost exterminated in exile and that we stayed in exile after the miracle illustrate how Purim has an undertone of sadness? In a sense, by rejoicing over what happened in Persia, aren’t we saying that we should remain in exile and that God will ultimately save us like he did the Jews of those days? Isn’t the entire Megillah, then, indirectly showing how horrible exile is and the importance of Jews controlling their own fate? Shouldn’t we not really then be celebrating at all?!
Answer
I believe your provocative question is important, and will try to relate to two aspects. 1. The undertone of sadness. 2. Why we rejoice at all.
In fact, there are several laws/customs that hint at the undertone you mentioned. The fast before the celebration requires that we take seriously the threat of anihalation. The talmud says, in one explanation, that we do not say Hallel on Purim because the miracle took place outside Israel, and in another, that we remained in exile (“servants of Achashveirosh”) . Our custom of reciting certain verses in the megila in the tune of lamentations also alludes to the sadness that is inherent in the story.
On the other hand, the existence of the Jewish people in the diaspora is miraculous, and not to rejoice at this wounndrous phenomenom seems to me to be the hight of ingratitude. Another aspect of Purim is the replacement of the prophetic tradition as the leading spiritual force in Jewish life with the centrality of the “chachamim” the Torah schlars, represented by Mordechai, who was one of he founders of the “Great assembly”. A third aspect is the fact that the Purim story led directly to the building of the second Temple and the return to Israel in the next generation. It seems to me that thes three points should be emphasized, and that we should make them a model for gratitude to HaShem for all his kindnesses.

Mishloach Manot
Rabbi David Sperling | Adar 20, 5772

Tachnun on Purim Meshulash
Rabbi David Sperling | Shevat 26, 5773

Purim and descendants of Jews who are non-Jews
Rabbi Yoel Lieberman | Adar II 19, 5774

Wine for Mishloach Manot
Various Rabbis | Adar I 15, 5768

Rabbi Chaim Tabasky
Rabbi Chaim Tabasky teaches a shiur in gemarah at the Beit Midrash program of the Machon Hagavoah l'Torah at Bar Ilan University. He is also a certified examiner of STa"M (Sifrei Torah, Tefillin and Mezuzot) and a narrative therapist.

Yirmeyahu 4:30
12 Sivan 5764

Can a Male Ger Become a Rabbi?
12 Av 5764

Crossing the International Dateline
20 Iyyar 5764

Women in the ’Halacha’
12 Sivan 5764

Krill Oil
Rabbi David Sperling | Tammuz 20, 5775

Vinegar and Davar Charif Soaking - Kavush
Rabbi David Sperling | Av 24, 5780

When does the Jewish day begin?
Rabbi David Sperling | Nisan 10, 5775

Mezzuzah for Non Jew
Rabbi David Sperling | Iyyar 18, 5773

Torah vs. Tanak additions
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Shevat 4, 5783
Apartment Eviction
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Shevat 9, 5783
How to split expenses for a group event
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Shevat 9, 5783
