Ask the Rabbi
- Halacha
- Prayer
- General Questions
Question
I arrive at Tefilot on Friday evening early. Since I’ve already brought in Shabbat for myself, what am I to do during Minchah?
I’ve been standing and responding during Kaddish, and standing during Kedushah. I don’t know whether I should respond during Kedushah. And I don’t know if it’s inappropriate to sit during the time that the others are reciting Shmoneh Esrei.
Answer
You can sit during the Amidah and Chazarat Hashatz and of course you can respond to Brachot and Kedusha.
You can learn or say Tehilim (Mishna Brura 90; 58) but not talk otherwise (Tefilah Kehilchata 13; 35).
You can't sit within 2 meters of someone that is in the middle of Tfilah unless you are in the middle of learning Torah. (Mishna Brura 102; 13)

Tfillat shav (Prayer false)
Rabbi David Sperling | Elul 9, 5775

Is it necessary to learn Hebrew?
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Tevet 10, 5783
Urine catheter bag at Davening
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Iyyar 11, 5770




