Ask the Rabbi
- Shabbat and Holidays
- Shabbat
- General Questions
Question
We were discussing the nature of bringing in Shabbat early. My question to my Rabbi which is still unanswered was whether or not someone who unknowlingly broke Shabbat (during the time when it was still when brought in early) would have had to bring a Korban in the days of the Temple or would the punishment be rabbinic in nature? Also, is being Yotzteh with an early Kiddush rabbinic or Deoritah (written or oral Torah directly derived)?
Answer
There is a question as to whether extending Shabbat is a Torah or rabbinic ordinance. In any case no sacrifice would be brought because the laws of punishment for the extension (Tosephet Shabbat) are not those of Shabbat itself.
Shabbat muktzeh
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Tevet 5, 5783

Shabbat in IDF
Rabbi Jonathan Blass | 24 Adar II 5763

Games on shabbos
Rabbi Eli Clark | Cheshvan 23, 5772





