Ask the Rabbi
- Torah and Jewish Thought
- Torah Study
- Torah Teachings
Question
Why does the Torah in Parashat Vayigash, Bereishit (46:12) list Yehuda’s two dead sons, Er and Onan, among the seventy who descended to Egypt?
Answer
The commentators on the Pasuk pick up on that and bring different explanations.
The Or HaChaim (Rabbi Chaim Ben Attar) suggests that it's because Yehuda is the "Yabam" and in a way he is the one to carry the name of the deceased as they die childless.
Similarly he brings another explanation that it's to find some merit points for them that they were influenced by the Egyptian culture and they were not bad essentially.
Rabenu Bachya brings a kabalistic comment – you can read it inside.
Kol tuv

Did Moses write the first five books of the Hebrew Bible?
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Sivan 24, 5774

Different versions of the Torah in Hebrew?
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Tammuz 8, 5774
What does this saying mean?
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Kislev 22, 5784





