Ask the Rabbi
  • Family and Society
  • Army and War
  • General Questions
ืงื˜ื’ื•ืจื™ื” ืžืฉื ื™ืช
undefined
Question
Last year I made Aliyah. Some months ago, I joined the Israeli Army. I serve in some pretty dangerous locations, but I tell my parents back in the States that I am working as a clerk in an equipment warehouse in a base near Tel Aviv. Is it OK to lie to them so that they wonโ€™t worry.
Answer
Our Sages teach that the world is predicated on truth, as it says, โ€œThe world stands on three things, on justice, on truth, and on peace.โ€[1] We are commanded to follow the ways of G-d. Just as He is truthful, so too, we should strive to be truthful in all of our ways.[2] Someone who distorts the truth is considered to be like an idol worshipper.[3] The Gemara teaches that Jerusalem was destroyed because of a lack of honest men within its walls.[4] In general, it is a good practice to be truthful. In fact, there is a commandment in the Torah which prohibits lying: โ€œKeep far away from an untruth.โ€[5] If a person lies in a court of law, he violates the Ten Commandments, โ€œYou shall not bear false witness.โ€[6] However, there are times when an individual can lie.Lying is permissible if its purpose is to maintain love and harmony between a man and his wife. We learn this from the life of Abraham and Sarah.[7] When G-d tells the aging Sarah that she will have a son, she laughs, saying how unlikely since her husband is so old. When G-d tells Abraham of Sarahโ€™s laughter, he changes the story saying that Sarah blamed her own old age, not her husbandโ€™s. Our Sages teach that G-d lied to preserve โ€œshalom bayitโ€ between husband and wife, to safeguard the harmony in their marriage.[8] This has many practical applications. For instance if a woman invariably puts too much salt in the Friday night soup, the husband can tell her that she is a wonderful cook without worrying about the prohibition against lying. Likewise, if a man is forty pounds overweight, his wife can still tell him that in her eyes he looks like a movie star. Harmony is so important that the permission to lie extends to bringing peace between any two individuals or groups.[9] The Sages of the House of Hillel taught that one can praise the beauty of a bride even though she is not particularly pretty.[10] It is also permissible to lie for the sake of humility. For instance, a Torah scholar of great quintessence is permitted to say that he hasnโ€™t learned any tractates of Talmud when in fact he has learned them all.[11] Furthermore, to safeguard a couple's privacy, a woman going to the Mikvah on the night of her ritual immersion is allowed to say that she is going to the movies.[11] The rabbis also permit lying in order to preserve a personโ€™s wellbeing. For instance, if one was wined and dined royally at the Levy's, if asked about the meal was, he can say it was โ€œnot badโ€ so that crowds of people wonโ€™t clamour for an invitation.[11] To avoid embarrassment, a person can lie. For instance, if someone has to enter the hospital for a hemorrhoid operation, he can tell people he is having his tonsils removed instead.[12] While there are cases were lying is permissible, one should do so very carefully. Our Sages teach that a habitual liar will not witness the presence of the Shechina.[13] In terms of lying to oneโ€™s parents to prevent them from worrying, it is better not to lie outright, but to present oneโ€™s explanation in a manner that is truthful without disclosing all of the disquieting details. So if you are serving in terrorist-infested Jenin, you can tell your parents that your are posted just north of Jerusalem. Since Jenin is merely an hourโ€™s drive away from Jerusalem, you wonโ€™t be guilty of a lie. 1. Avot, 1:18. 2. Deuteronomy, 28:9. 3. Sanhedrin 92A. 4. Shabbat 119B. 5. Exodus, 23:7. 6. Ibid, 20:12. 7. Genesis, 18:12-13. 8. Baba Metzia, 87A. 9. Yevamot 65B. 10. Ketubot, 17A. 11. Baba Metzia 23B. 12. P'ninei Halacha, Vol. 3, Pg. 159, based on the Rambam, Laws of Theft, 14:13. 13. Sotah 42A.
Ask a follow-up question
Popular Questions
Popular Questions
Recent Questions
Recent Questions
ืืช ื”ืžื™ื“ืข ื”ื“ืคืกืชื™ ื‘ืืžืฆืขื•ืช ืืชืจ yeshiva.org.il